Current public sentiment towards the housing market?

Status
Not open for further replies.
The UK situation is in many (or at least some) ways similar to Ireland and despite BOE base rates of 4.75% there has been no collapse. It may take an external shock to Ireland to finally push the market over the edge, otherwise it may simply continue for a long period with lower or no price increases and lower levels of activity in the market. A major crash can really only happen with a major increase in unemployment and its not easy that easy for me to see that in the short term.

The thing is that the UK actually manufacture stuff that they sell to the rest of the world. They don't emply 15% of their workforce in construction. Construction doesn't account for 20% of GDP in the UK. The UK's credit bubble is about half of what ours is, on a per-person basis.
 
I am bearish overall in the medium to long term, but I don’t think anybody should dismiss Rico's comments out of hand. The UK situation is in many (or at least some) ways similar to Ireland and despite BOE base rates of 4.75% there has been no collapse. It may take an external shock to Ireland to finally push the market over the edge, otherwise it may simply continue for a long period with lower or no price increases and lower levels of activity in the market. A major crash can really only happen with a major increase in unemployment and its not easy that easy for me to see that in the short term.

In the medium term lower levels of construction will lead to a reduction in those employed in that industry but as a lot of those people are immigrants who rent I cant see that effecting demand for housing. Investors have already shown themselves more than willing to put up with 1.5% - 2.0% returns provided they own asset they believe will appreciate in the long run.

IMO we are looking at a long slow deflation of the bubble rather than a pop. Sorry for those who were looking forward to gloating over their home owning friends/collegues but this isnt going to be so clear cut.

The reason the UK is not collapsing is because the BoE is going a juggling act trying to control inflation whilst not bringing the UK economy to it's knees. The jury is out on whether or not they've actually controlled inflation - time will tell.

There is one crucial difference - the UK has control over it's own interest rate - we don't. Trichet is primarily worried about Germany and France. We're a rounding error, let's face it. If we get hung out to dry, they won't care.
 
The UK situation is in many (or at least some) ways similar to Ireland and despite BOE base rates of 4.75% there has been no collapse.
UK situation is completely different. Irish bubble is far more inflated. Also the lowest point for UK interest rates was 3.5% and even then only for 5 months in 2003. Euro rates were at 2% for two and a half years between July 2003 and Dec 2005 - and interest rate increases are proportionally far larger than the UK.

IMO we are looking at a long slow deflation of the bubble rather than a pop. Sorry for those who were looking forward to gloating over their home owning friends/collegues but this isnt going to be so clear cut.
Agreed, I think will be slow but relentless. Probably take a few years for the crash to play out. Japan took quite a while.
 
I am bearish overall in the medium to long term, but I don’t think anybody should dismiss Rico's comments out of hand. The UK situation is in many (or at least some) ways similar to Ireland and despite BOE base rates of 4.75% there has been no collapse. It may take an external shock to Ireland to finally push the market over the edge, otherwise it may simply continue for a long period with lower or no price increases and lower levels of activity in the market. A major crash can really only happen with a major increase in unemployment and its not easy that easy for me to see that in the short term.

In the medium term lower levels of construction will lead to a reduction in those employed in that industry but as a lot of those people are immigrants who rent I cant see that effecting demand for housing. Investors have already shown themselves more than willing to put up with 1.5% - 2.0% returns provided they own asset they believe will appreciate in the long run.

IMO we are looking at a long slow deflation of the bubble rather than a pop. Sorry for those who were looking forward to gloating over their home owning friends/collegues but this isnt going to be so clear cut.

The UK is a debt ridden, deficit junkie economy, please don't compare Ireland to the UK. (Trade has not contributed to economic growth in the UK since 1995). And if a crash happens reserve your bile for the shysters who profited from the shell game not the onlookers please.
 


Trichet is primarily worried about Germany and France. We're a rounding error, let's face it. If we get hung out to dry, they won't care.

especially since we ignored all the warnings and since we havent pulled out weight in the EU despite the Celtic Tiger we still are not a Net contributer to the EU
 
d) Property has always had strongest attraction to Irish people and homeownership and improving/trading up activity will continue.

The property trade-up market is only as strong as its weakest link, namely FTB.
 
I wonder are Rico and Panzraam wolves in estate agents clothing?

Sentiment drove the lemming like rush to the top and sentiment will lead to the lemming like rush to escape.

It will not happen overnight, but happen it will. Confidence is the corner stone of capitalism, take away confidence and we are left with an economey whose foundations are built on sand.

The tide of debt is rising and has been for a long time. We are not as rich as we think we are and a lot of people are going to find out that they are not as smart as they would like to think.
 
so far we have discovered 4 real bears, who sold within 1 year period and now renting.

also 1 or 2 who sold in last couple of years for multiple reasons, including travel, going abroad etc etc and dint buy on their return, so i guess we can call them half real bears.

any more? there should be lot more here seeing peoples sentiment here in general.

ok here is an update, so far 6 real bears and two half bears...
and rest are either hiding or have nothing more to show apart from their opinions.
come on out of hundreds postings on this forum only 8 bears?

still waiting on more responses, from investors who are reducing their holdings, or owners moving to rental properties.
 
Absolutely not. At least they won't lose their construction-related jobs! It'll be Paddy the Plasterer (not that one!) and Brenda the Bank-Employee who'll be hit worst.

bankers are not gonna hit anytime soon, their stocks still making all time highs. market will turn before them getting hit.
 
Let's speculate:
- Flipper/short term speculator: Are in trouble now, trying to get out and may be able to lock in profits if you sell quickly.
- Investor, rent covers mortgage, good yield (bought in 1998): You may have trouble finding renters, but you should emerge ok
- Investor, subsidising rent: Screwed when prices start falling. Can't afford to sell and can't afford to subsidise the rent.
- Home owner, bought in area they like living, 2006, can afford mortgage: You'll survive, but some of your neighbours will be paying half the mortgage you have to pay for the same type of property.
- Home owner, bought to "get on ladder" - can afford mortgage, don't like area: You're going to be stuck there for 10-15 years.

interesting...

no speculation on people like myself(and probable like yourself) who dont own? i guess we will be picking properties at 50% discount soon, right?
looks like everyone is in trouble except ppl like u and me, smart aint we lol
 
interesting...

no speculation on people like myself(and probable like yourself) who dont own? i guess we will be picking properties at 50% discount soon, right?
looks like everyone is in trouble except ppl like u and me, smart aint we lol

And if interest rates rise to 6% ECB rate...won't you still end up paying almost the same amount over time, except it will be to a lender rather than a vendor.
 
I don't have a house and have no intention of buying, does that not make me a bear.

Well I hope to sell my PPR and rent if it isn't already too late; I'd happily accept a 10% underbid on the asking price of nearby properties too. But it's pragmatic bearish behaviour - we intend to trade up anyway and part of the plan is to rent somewhere we'd ideally like to buy to see how practical this turns out so even if it ends up costing (and the numbers are quite scary if next year sees a 10% rise), it won't entirely be wasted money.
 
Off topic I know, but we ARE a net contributor to the EU and always have been...just ask our fishermen about our quota of 4% of the EU catch with 25% of the fish at our doorstep....meanwhile the farmers get handouts for keeping land in clover!!!

Firefly.
 
Three Bulls on newstalk this morning all spoke of Price correction or soft landing, very keen not to mention crash..Bad time for investors never a bad time for buying to live in..Changing of stamp duty was also mentioned, the average punter will hold out signing contracts till after the budget.

I think the Lucans and Clonees of this world are going to be most badly effected.
 
Three Bulls on newstalk this morning all spoke of Price correction or soft landing, very keen not to mention crash..Bad time for investors never a bad time for buying to live in..Changing of stamp duty was also mentioned, the average punter will hold out signing contracts till after the budget.

.

Newstalk seems to have a continous run of bulls on recently. The presenter doesn't ever seem to ask hard questions of them, did he this morning?
 
plenty of properties listed on page 3 of todays Indo selling for above their AMV .
 
From Today's Irish Times:

Mortgage borrowers hit by further interest rate rise

[broken link removed]

This rediculous comment from Labour Party's finance spokeswoman - obviously doesn't understand basic economics!

Labour Party finance spokeswoman Joan Burton criticised yesterday's decision as unnecessary.
"Given the recent recovery in European markets over the last year, it is difficult to understand why the ECB is continuing with this series of increases," she said.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top