Ok the saga continues, I did visit my Intreo office and spoke with 2 gentlemen, one called the second one over to see his opinion as neither were too sure - one just kept repeating that I cannot be in receipt of 2 benefits and my only option was to appeal the decision. They advised me to put a letter together with any other documents and bring them back to the office for them to forward, I did this and when I returned I was at a different hatch and was asked if i had filled out the appeal form which the other 2 had failed to give me, I duly filled it out and returned to the hatch with my appeal letters and it's in the hands of the God's now. I think it could also come down to semantics as the Americans call the Social Security Retirement payment a benefit, whereas I would call it a pension.?? They say garbage we say rubbish!!!