Descart
My opinion that there is no realistic likelihood that the Supreme Court would permit an appeal from the Court of Appeal in this matter obviously cannot pre-date the establishment of the Court of Appeal!
No, I do not believe Irish contract law trumps any valid legislative provision, whether of European origin or otherwise.
You now seem to be arguing that Ireland has not properly implemented the Unfair Contracts Directive. I disagree, but you can certainly make your case in this regard to the Commission.
You are obviously entitled to your personal view that the Supreme Court would permit an appeal from the Court of Appeal to proceed on this matter. I obviously disagree with your personal view in this regard and furthermore I do not agree that there is anything exceptional about this case such that permitting an appeal from the Court of Appeal to proceed would be warranted.
My opinion that there is no realistic likelihood that the Supreme Court would permit an appeal from the Court of Appeal in this matter obviously cannot pre-date the establishment of the Court of Appeal!
No, I do not believe Irish contract law trumps any valid legislative provision, whether of European origin or otherwise.
You now seem to be arguing that Ireland has not properly implemented the Unfair Contracts Directive. I disagree, but you can certainly make your case in this regard to the Commission.
You are obviously entitled to your personal view that the Supreme Court would permit an appeal from the Court of Appeal to proceed on this matter. I obviously disagree with your personal view in this regard and furthermore I do not agree that there is anything exceptional about this case such that permitting an appeal from the Court of Appeal to proceed would be warranted.