We don't need the CRO? ODCE? Employment rights enforcement and a court of arbitration? HSA? An office to issue work permits? Labour court? Import/export licencing? Consumer agency? Competition authority?
The ENTIRE department?
We don't need the CRO? ODCE? Employment rights enforcement and a court of arbitration? HSA? An office to issue work permits? Labour court? Import/export licencing? Consumer agency? Competition authority?
Chris - Ayn Rand called she's looking for copyright infringement!
Great - I look forward to bringing my net salary up to the levels of the gross salary of my comparators in the private sector - woohoo!Yes, as a net cost to the taxpayer, i.e. the private sector, I have no problem with that calculation being used. I don't think I have ever criticized public sector pay in general. There are things that governments should be doing and I have no problem paying those people adequately for their efforts and looking at the net cost to the taxpayer. My issue has always been with the size of government in total being far far too large.
I am personally not in favour of arbitrary pay cuts, but rather to limiting government in size at the very least to its revenue, by getting rid of services that are not crucial, or are totally unnecessary and useless.
Great - so let's get rid of Dept Agriculture, and bring on the horse burgers, in a rat milk sauce, with a fricasee of dog - consumers will just sort it out, right?We've had these discussion many times, but here are some off the top of my head:
- Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine: get rid of it; farmers will still farm, and food producers will still produce food; despite fishing quotas that nobody understands fish stocks are apparently still on the brink making this department either incompetent or incapable (saving €870ml)
- Department of Arts, Heritage and the Gaeltacht: get rid of it altogether, people will survive (saving €260ml)
- Department of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation: get rid of it altogether, governments cannot create jobs, they can only pose a barrier (saving €805ml)
- Department of Public Expenditure and Reform: get rid of it, we do not need a department to get rid of other departments (saving €865ml)
- Department of Transport, Tourism and Sport: get rid of it; people will still visit here and play sports, and government should not be monopolizing the transport market (saving €1.6bn)
- Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade: get rid of it, government does not facilitate trade, companies are perfectly able to trade; and in today's day and age we do not need consulates all over the world (saving €660ml)
- get rid of all motor tax offices; they are totally unnecessary when you can pay over the internet, phone, post and I think even in the post office (savings ???)
WOuldn't Ryanair and other large providers just love to see the Competition Authority being taken away?CRO: No need for it, companies will exist without a piece of paper that say they are registered. It is red tape, nothing more.
ODCE: Enforcement of laws should be done through the justice system, we do not need a separate office to complicate matters.
Employment rights/court of arbitration/labour court: Same thing, we have a justice system, which needs to be overhauled, but that is no reason for a separate court system.
Work Permits: I'm an open boarders kind if guy. If someone wants to come here and work in a legal activity, then let them do it (without the support of the taxpayer). Ireland once supported a population of more than 8 million; the US and Canada became great economies because of immigration.
Import/export licencing: Why do we need to restrict who imports or exports what and when, by handing out licences? This restricts trade and does not advance it.
Consumer agency: Consumers are perfectly capable of looking after themselves, without the help of the NCA. When people buy stuff, do they go to the NCA for advice or do they do a bit of research online to find consumer and expert reviews? And if they believe they have been wronged or defrauded with their purchase the there is at the very least the small claims court. And in bigger cases the justice system.
Competition authority: Competition is a natural phenomenon in a free market environment. We do not need an "authority" to check if a company is being anti-competitive. If there is lack of competition, and there is actually a viable market, but there are no new companies entering the market, then it is due to restrictions put in place by government, like the above mentioned licencing for example.
Can you explain how you managed to get to that conclusion from what Chris said above?Great - I look forward to bringing my net salary up to the levels of the gross salary of my comparators in the private sector - woohoo!
Why have an entire department to look after enforcement of standards?Great - so let's get rid of Dept Agriculture, and bring on the horse burgers, in a rat milk sauce, with a fricasee of dog - consumers will just sort it out, right?
I was as the Cliffs of Moher before and it wasn’t because there was a guy from the Dept of Tourism standing behind me with a pointy stick.Let's get rid of the Dept of Tourism, and along with it the 1million visitors that come to the Cliffs of Moher Visitor Centre every hear.
Enterprise Ireland don’t give any support to Foreign Direct Investment companies and never have. They support Irish companies seeking to export, or at least they are meant to. They do great work in some areas but in my experience, working with them for over a decade, about 80% of what they do is a waste of time and money.Let's get rid of Enterprise Ireland, and the supports that it gives to the Foreign Direct Investment companies to match the supports offered in other countries.
Why would museums all close just because a department closed down?Let's get rid of the Dept of Arts Heritage and Gaeltacht, and close down the National Museum, the National Gallery and many other supported arts and cultural venues (all providing employment and bringing in tourists of course).
I would imagine that that will not be the case as your total compensation will have to include the true net value of your pension.Great - I look forward to bringing my net salary up to the levels of the gross salary of my comparators in the private sector - woohoo!
We have that department and yet burgers were still produced with horse meat. Hundreds of millions spent every year on a FAILED system. There is no way the use of horse meat is a new phenomenon, it has been going of for years undetected. If there was no department in charge of this, then people would not have the false sense of security over food quality. People do research before they buy computers, or cars or book hotels, but when it comes to government regulated industries there is a blind faith. If there was no designated department then people would do their research and check up on independent expert reviews, just like they do with so many other things they buy.Great - so let's get rid of Dept Agriculture, and bring on the horse burgers, in a rat milk sauce, with a fricasee of dog - consumers will just sort it out, right?
Do you honestly think that people go to the Cliffs of Moher to look at the visitor center? They go there to look at the cliffs and they will still be there without a department of tourism.Let's get rid of the Dept of Tourism, and along with it the 1million visitors that come to the Cliffs of Moher Visitor Centre every hear.
Foreign companies invest here because of the tax rates, not because of Enterprise Ireland. FDI did not increase in the 90s because of Enterprise Ireland, or the IDA or any other government service. It increased because corporate taxes were low and overall red tape was, and to an extent still is, comparatively low.Let's get rid of Enterprise Ireland, and the supports that it gives to the Foreign Direct Investment companies to match the supports offered in other countries.
They don't need to close down, they can still be operated by a private enterprise. The reason there is no competition or private alternative in these areas is because people that visit those museums do not pay, which gives them an unfair advantage over any potential private enterprise. Just because government doesn't do something doesn't mean that it wouldn't be done. Government does not make shoes or phones or car tires, but yet we have plenty of choices in those areas. Why would it be any different in museums or visitor centers?Let's get rid of the Dept of Arts Heritage and Gaeltacht, and close down the National Museum, the National Gallery and many other supported arts and cultural venues (all providing employment and bringing in tourists of course).
They probably would, but they would also HATE to see the market opened to competitors of all sizes.WOuldn't Ryanair and other large providers just love to see the Competition Authority being taken away?
No they don't. People need to take responsibility for their own actions, and if they are defrauded then they should take legal action. I should not have to pay for someone else's mistakes.WOuld these self-empowered consumers include the many consumers who fell for for the simple Slovenian mobile phone scam over the weekend? Sure they don't need any Govt agency to get refunds for them - right?
I did mention that the entire legal system needs to be overhauled. Courts should be operating longer hours and more days; we need to get rid of the barrister system; it should not be mandatory to have a qualified solicitor/barrister represent you in certain courts; the list goes on. The small claims courts system is a perfect example of how to speed up and reduce the cost of certain cases.And how exactly to you get savings by moving enforcement functions from ODCE and employment rights tribunals back into the general court system, which is already overloaded and does not have the skill, knowledge or capacity to deal with these cases?
No, you, and many other people, simply believe that if government doesn't do certain things then they will not be done and everything will disintegrate. There is simply no evidence for such a belief; actually quite the opposite is the case.Unfortunately, the theory doesn't work too well in the real world.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?