prize bonds win tax implications

nearlyoldfellow said:
Just won a couple of €75 on the Prize Bonds in the last 3 months. Are the winnings tax free or do they have to be declared ?
Click to expand...
There are two questions here.
Yes they are tax free.
But the unanswered one is do you have to declare them?

I dont know the answer but in the same way rent a room below the threshold is tax free, you still are supposed to declare it.
 
I've never bothered declaring any (marginal) PB winnings myself.

FWIW (maybe nothing) ChatGPT says that you don't need to declare them unlike some other forms of tax exempt income.

Me:​

In Ireland Prize Bonds winnings are exempt from DIRT, income tax, PRSI and USC. However is one still supposed to declare such winnings on one's tax return even if they are exempt from those liabilities?

ChatGPT said:​

In Ireland, Prize Bond winnings are indeed exempt from Deposit Interest Retention Tax (DIRT), income tax, PRSI, and the Universal Social Charge (USC). However, despite this tax-exempt status, there is no requirement to declare these winnings on your tax return. Since they are fully exempt from tax liabilities, you do not need to report them to the Revenue Commissioners.
This differs from certain other forms of income or gains, where you might need to declare them even if no tax is payable. Prize Bonds fall outside that requirement entirely.
Click to expand...

Me:​

Can you cite any Revenue documentation to support that analysis?

ChatGPT said:​

Yes, I can provide references from the Irish Revenue Commissioners to support this analysis.

1. Revenue's Tax and Duty Manual (Part 07-01-13):

In the Tax and Duty Manual, Part 07-01-13 titled "Exemption of certain prizes and winnings from tax", the Revenue explicitly states:
  • Prize Bonds: "Winnings from Prize Bonds are exempt from income tax, Universal Social Charge (USC), and Pay Related Social Insurance (PRSI). There is no requirement to declare these winnings on your tax return."
This manual clarifies that since Prize Bond winnings are fully exempt, they do not need to be reported.

2. Revenue's Leaflet IT1 - "Tax Credits, Reliefs and Rates":

Under the section "Exempt Income", the leaflet mentions:
  • Tax-Free Winnings: "Winnings from betting, lotteries, sweepstakes, and Prize Bonds are not liable to income tax and should not be included in your tax return."
3. Revenue's Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) on Taxable Income:

On the Revenue website, in the FAQs regarding taxable income, it is stated:
  • Do I need to declare tax-exempt income? "You do not need to declare income that is exempt from tax, such as Prize Bond winnings, unless you are specifically required to do so under certain circumstances."
References:
  • Revenue Commissioners - Tax and Duty Manuals: www.revenue.ie
  • Leaflet IT1 - Tax Credits, Reliefs and Rates: Available under the Forms and Leaflets section on the Revenue website.
  • Revenue FAQs on Taxable Income: Accessible through the Help or FAQs section on www.revenue.ie
Conclusion:

Based on the above Revenue documentation, you are not required to declare Prize Bond winnings on your tax return since they are fully exempt from income tax, USC, and PRSI.
Click to expand...
 
Last edited:
ClubMan said:

Me:​

Can you cite any Revenue documentation to support that analysis?

ChatGPT said:​

Yes, I can provide references from the Irish Revenue Commissioners to support this analysis.

1. Revenue's Tax and Duty Manual (Part 07-01-13):

In the Tax and Duty Manual, Part 07-01-13 titled "Exemption of certain prizes and winnings from tax", the Revenue explicitly states:
  • Prize Bonds: "Winnings from Prize Bonds are exempt from income tax, Universal Social Charge (USC), and Pay Related Social Insurance (PRSI). There is no requirement to declare these winnings on your tax return."
This manual clarifies that since Prize Bond winnings are fully exempt, they do not need to be reported.

2. Revenue's Leaflet IT1 - "Tax Credits, Reliefs and Rates":

Under the section "Exempt Income", the leaflet mentions:
  • Tax-Free Winnings: "Winnings from betting, lotteries, sweepstakes, and Prize Bonds are not liable to income tax and should not be included in your tax return."
3. Revenue's Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) on Taxable Income:

On the Revenue website, in the FAQs regarding taxable income, it is stated:
  • Do I need to declare tax-exempt income? "You do not need to declare income that is exempt from tax, such as Prize Bond winnings, unless you are specifically required to do so under certain circumstances."
References:
  • Revenue Commissioners - Tax and Duty Manuals: www.revenue.ie
  • Leaflet IT1 - Tax Credits, Reliefs and Rates: Available under the Forms and Leaflets section on the Revenue website.
  • Revenue FAQs on Taxable Income: Accessible through the Help or FAQs section on www.revenue.ie
Conclusion:

Based on the above Revenue documentation, you are not required to declare Prize Bond winnings on your tax return since they are fully exempt from income tax, USC, and PRSI.
Click to expand...

Unfortunately, this tells us a lot more about ChatGPT than it does about Prize Bonds.

In the Tax and Duty Manual, Part 07-01-13 titled "Exemption of certain prizes and winnings from tax", the Revenue explicitly states:
  • Prize Bonds: "Winnings from Prize Bonds are exempt from income tax, Universal Social Charge (USC), and Pay Related Social Insurance (PRSI). There is no requirement to declare these winnings on your tax return."
Click to expand...

Part 07-01-13 of the TDM is entitled "United Nations and Specialised Agencies of the United Nations" and has nothing whatsoever to say about Prize Bonds

The Tax Emption relating to Prize Bonds (and other State Savings products) is covered in part 19-07-10 of the TDM "Miscellaneous exemptions for certain kinds of property". There is no mention in this section of a reporting requirement, neither in the negative nor affirmative.

2. Revenue's Leaflet IT1 - "Tax Credits, Reliefs and Rates":

Under the section "Exempt Income", the leaflet mentions:
  • Tax-Free Winnings: "Winnings from betting, lotteries, sweepstakes, and Prize Bonds are not liable to income tax and should not be included in your tax return."
Click to expand...

Revenue Leaflet IT1 is long defunct. Replaced by information panels on the revenue.ie website.

The last version of IT1 that I can find, dated 2016, does not contain the wording quoted, and in fact makes no mention of reporting in relation to Prize Bond Winnings.

3. Revenue's Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) on Taxable Income:

On the Revenue website, in the FAQs regarding taxable income, it is stated:
  • Do I need to declare tax-exempt income? "You do not need to declare income that is exempt from tax, such as Prize Bond winnings, unless you are specifically required to do so under certain circumstances."
Click to expand...

I have failed to find this working anywhere on revenue.ie. Furthermore, the mention of prize bonds here is oddly specific. And for anyone familiar with the Revenue conduct themselves (especially the current closed minded and tightlipped regime) the wording sounds quite unlike Revenue.

In summary, the three sections of this response look to be made up crap, wrapping the offending text in quotation marks exacerbates the error as it lends an air of authenticity and none of the source links point to the erroneous text.

Perhaps posting ChatGPT generated rubbish as a response to a legitimate question is not a great idea.
 
I don't think regurgitated ChatGPT answers are appropriate on a forum like this. People want a human answer otherwise they would just Google it themselves. Not someone to paste their question into a AI.

It's a useful tool and even if the general thrust of an answer is right, all the details are guff and need to be individually checked, preferably before being posted.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top