Exactly - so saving the premiums might (a) cover your costs anyway and (b) leave you with a lump sum if nothing happens. Insurance should really only be taken out for eventualities that would give rise to costs that you would be very hard pressed to cover yourself (e.g. the house burning down) not for lesser expenses. I would imagine that the chances of having vet bills of €500+ every year for pets would be unlikely so to insure at such a premium seems crazy to me.
To be honest clubman in our case with pedigree dogs who already have had problems and problems which will keep coming back I just prefer the safety net of insurance - I just don't want to be caught short - i.e something bad happens to dog and I can't afford lump sum cos I haven't saved it or I saved it but spent it!.
bit of the topic but well before insurance for pets was invented - approx 10 years ago we had an amazing cat - anyway one day he came home with a small cut in his paw - as the days progressed small cut turned into big cut and so on -so one night cat kept falling around the place - really weak. Took him to emergency vet in Castleknock at about 2 in the morning - she didn't know what it was but kept him in on a drip - he remained here for about 3 weeks - the charge was about 40 (pounds) per day for drip and various tests. she then rings and says cat needs to go to Ballsbridge Vet College for more tests. They kept the cat for 2 months - turns out it had feline leprosy - paw healed cat came home - ran off one month later! Anyway back then this was huge money for my parents . Over the years we've had a number of incidents (expensive ones) with pets so when we realised you could insure your pet we jumped at it. €500 with a good vet won't get you that far - tests and operations for animals are hugely expensive so I think we'll keep up the insurance. Only thing that does really annoy me is that your premium never goes down unlike car insurance - Pet gets older - premium gets higher