whether ex union is right , or wrong . about what the union said . i keep saying this and nobody seems to accept it . THIS IS NONE OF THE UNIONS BUSINESS . this whole esop thing has nothing to do with ANY trade union , it is a company set up for the purposes of distributing shares to participents . no union within eircom , trade union , or credit union or any other kind of union has any right to know what is going on in relation to our shares before the members themselves . i object strongly to a situation where NONE MEMBERS of esop , TRADE UNION , OR CREDIT UNION should be advised of what the state of play is before us . i have noticed all down through the years that the union will only associate itself with esop when things are going well , when things are NOT going so well they tell you they have nothing to do with esop and thats a fact