We have all been massively wronged and should protest

The last time they were in government from 94 to 97,

It's a long time ago though. I think Labour would set us back competitively and as for Enda...everytime I see him, I think about The Breffmeister from The Apprentice !
 
In effect, this may be where the PS/CS has a lot of power in that if they were united they could shift the balance in the next election. There are certainly plenty of days I wish I had the power to elect or not my own employer. So in a nut shell could FF be voted out for the pay cuts, if you had the entire PS/CS vote against them, maybe.

Fair point but I would not be surprised if at the next election some PS/CS employees still vote FF, given the nature of party loyalty in this country.
I think if FF are voted out it will be more to do with getting us into this mess than the steps they are taking to get us out of it.
 
It's a long time ago though. I think Labour would set us back competitively and as for Enda...everytime I see him, I think about The Breffmeister from The Apprentice !

I agree re: Enda. I can't believe he is the most capable leader FG can put forward. FG claim that he is a good manager of people rather than a charismatic leader. This is probably just spin but as I said in another post, Bertie consistently scored high in approval polls when in office and he will prob go down as one of our worst leaders.
 
I have to disagree based on speaking to colleagues overseas. A view has developed that there is no point in doing business with a government that could be thrown out at any time (1 breavement could do it) and almost certainly wont be in power for the forseeable future.

In times of crisis you need stability and public support. The current government has neither and this impacts on everything they do.

You also totally discount public confidence. We cannot install public confidence in our economy with the current government. Public confidence and support encourages people to start in business, expand their business, increases consumer confidence and spending etc etc. This alone yield a couple percentage points of growth per annum.



FF has proven that it doesnt have the appetite for the tough decisions that are necessary. It picks the low lying fruit such as public service wages, stealth taxes, squeeze the middle ranking PAYE worker. It has a 100% flunk rate on the decisions that are needed to get our country going i.e.

1. Take the hit on Anglo NOW - dont throw good money after bad.
2. Significant reform of the health service (eliminate admin waste).
3. Significant reform of SW with an emphasis on protecting the temporary unemployed person and reducing payments to those who are able, but have no intention of working.
4. Cleanout of banking executives - why on earth is the government negotiating with the executives who got us into this mess? They should be negotiating with the owners i.e. the shareholders and saying clean your bank up and sack the incompetents or you wont be in the guarantee.
5. Meaningful reform of the public sector i.e. eliminating the unnecessary through compulsory redundancies rather than the broad brush cut the everyones wages so that those who do a meaningful job suffer to keep those who dont employed.

Regarding foreign investors, I think we will agree to disagree on that point . . While I wont pretend to be an economist (or anything of the sort), I work in financial services sector and the word on the ground (certainly the one's I'm hearing and reading in foreign media outlets), is that there is a positive sentiment towards Ireland.

Remember we have been mentioned in the same brackets as Greece, yet so far we havent even come close to their crisis. . Nothing to sing and dance about, but the decisions our government took were really well considered, especially as it involved protecting bondholders (one of the reasons this was done was so these guys will reinvest in Ireland).

I think you are missing my point . . Part of the public anger at the government is that they are bailing out investors . . Do you think these investors would prefer a happy Ireland, but no refund of their investment ? Like it or not, Ireland is a country that honors its debts and protects investors in time of crisis . . Im not saying I agree with this ideology, but as an investor you could only be happy.

As far as public confidence in Ireland. What country in the world has a happy government or happy public ? You forget that most countries are dealing with their own crisis . . Snap elections are not a solution to civil unrest in our situation. . I still dont see how you think a new government (3 years into a term) will convince people Ireland has solved its civil unrest, it could very well lead to more elections over less terms as the new government rolls back on promises it was never going to be able to keep. We need the problem stabilized and then we can pick the right government for the future. Right now, people voting while angry will make rash decisions and ask very little of their T.D.'s ("just dont be like FF) . .

Right now, we need to get the collective heads down and dig Ireland out of this crisis . . When the dust has settled, then you go after the dodgy politicians and the rogue bankers who have gotten away with too much for too long . . I think that Ireland, as a nation, needs to grow up and earn the right to be run fairly . . I think a new Ireland can be created on an election born out of anger, but not right now. . People need time to assess what happened and why . . Then you demand that your local TD show the principles that you feel is right for the country . .Doesn't matter what TD it is . . Say that the only way they will get your vote is by showing moral leadership and transparent plans.

That aside, I dont necessarily disagree with your 5 points, but what makes you so sure that FG or labour will implement these reforms ? Again, my point isnt that people should vote FF, its that they should demand this off whoever they are voting for . . Whatever anybody thinks of FF, they were the majority party for the guts of two decades, so you need only look at the electorate if you want to point fingers . .

I simply dont have confidence in our society/electorate and I believe they need to grow up and start making rational, educated decisions based on whats good for the country (not just whats good for them). But we simply are not at that stage yet. With that in mind, I believe we would end up voting in a populist government with a completely backwards agenda that's all about just not being FF. . One year down the road (if they last that long), after listening to them make excuses on why they couldnt make any progress on their promises (its all FFs fault for leaving this mess. . Waffle waffle waffl), we would be looking for a new government . .

Having an election and voting in the very weak opposition in power (without any real expectation other then that they wont be FF) is like jumping into bed with a bird who looks like your ex girlfriend (who cheated on you) just in spite of your ex . .

Yes we need change . . But the most important change needs to be in the attitudes and morals of the electorate . .
 
I think if FF are voted out it will be more to do with getting us into this mess than the steps they are taking to get us out of it.
Yes, I agree. Much of the ranting about what FF are doing now seems to have more to do with deflected anger at peoples own stupidity over the last few years. What Bertie and many of the existing bunch of mutton-heads did is tantamount to treason but that’s no reason not to look what they are doing at the moment in a rational way. I would vote for any party that was going to make Brian Lenihan minister for finance. I would vote against any party that would put Bertie in charge.

I have voted against FF in the last few elections. I would vote for them if there was an election tomorrow.
 
Returning a government that hasnt worked and isnt working = 0% chance of change.

With every other combination of parties there is % chance that there will be change for the better - I admit for some parties, it may be a small percentage (and for others it may be a large one), but a small percent chance is better than no chance.
 
@purple

Could you explain your post a bit more??? Are you not aware that it was FF that led us into this crisis? And why vote for a crowd that screwed you? That is perverse and if that is the normal approach we are doomed. A minister for finance is a figurehead! Are you then saying if lenihan goes to fianna gael you will vote fianna gael???

lost
 
Returning a government that hasnt worked and isnt working = 0% chance of change.

With every other combination of parties there is % chance that there will be change for the better - I admit for some parties, it may be a small percentage (and for others it may be a large one), but a small percent chance is better than no chance.

You just dont seem to get it . . You are advocating change for the sake of it . . Like "sure we cant do much worse can we!" . . Seriously, people need never wonder how we are in such a state . .

Lenihan has been the only shining light in the Dail for many a year (I include the opposition in that) . . Hes actually the only politician whose hand I would dearly love to shake. I think he has bee superb and gets better the longer he is in that position . . Only for him, I think we would be sitting with Greece as the basketcase of Europe.

That aside, Im not talking about returning the same government, Im just not ruling out FF because the name is a dirty word . . As a nation, if we really want to learn from our mistakes we need to accept that we all made mistakes and one of them was not thinking of the greater good of the country . . If we truely want change, it shouldnt be just a change of party, it has to be a change of culture . .
 
@purple

Could you explain your post a bit more??? Are you not aware that it was FF that led us into this crisis? And why vote for a crowd that screwed you? That is perverse and if that is the normal approach we are doomed. A minister for finance is a figurehead! Are you then saying if lenihan goes to fianna gael you will vote fianna gael???

lost
FF are a party made up of people. If the people change then then the nature of the party changes. The same applies to most other parties. Policies and the ability of the people in a position to run with them are what matters.
BTW, the finance minister is far more than a figure head.
 
It's a long time ago though. I think Labour would set us back competitively and as for Enda...everytime I see him, I think about The Breffmeister from The Apprentice !


It was FG who were largely in -control of Local Government during the Celtic Tiger.

Zonings and planning permissions were given - to ghost estates and unwanted houses in the middle of no-where.
 
You just dont seem to get it . . You are advocating change for the sake of it . . Like "sure we cant do much worse can we!" . . Seriously, people need never wonder how we are in such a state . .

Lenihan has been the only shining light in the Dail for many a year (I include the opposition in that) . . Hes actually the only politician whose hand I would dearly love to shake. I think he has bee superb and gets better the longer he is in that position . . Only for him, I think we would be sitting with Greece as the basketcase of Europe.

That aside, Im not talking about returning the same government, Im just not ruling out FF because the name is a dirty word . . As a nation, if we really want to learn from our mistakes we need to accept that we all made mistakes and one of them was not thinking of the greater good of the country . . If we truely want change, it shouldnt be just a change of party, it has to be a change of culture . .

No, you just dont get it. You forget that the government is at fault for having us in this crisis to begin with. If someone else had been in power in recent years, then any comparisons with Greece would be irrelevant.

I think you are displaying classic victim of bullying denial behaviour. You know you are getting a raw deal, but your confidence has been damaged so much that you think that you dont deserve any better or that you cannot survive without the bully.

Believe me, we can do a lot better.
 
It was FG who were largely in -control of Local Government during the Celtic Tiger.

Zonings and planning permissions were given - to ghost estates and unwanted houses in the middle of no-where.
I'm sure the party is very proud of your ongoing attempts to deflect responsibility away from Fianna Fail, but most people will see through these feeble attempts.

FG didn't set planning policy - that came out of Dept Environment under FF ministers. FG didn't appoint the members of An Bord Pleanala, who repeatedly overruled any attempts by local authorities to hold back on development. FF appointed these people.
 
If someone else had been in power in recent years, then any comparisons with Greece would be irrelevant.

The only thing the opposition said after successive give-away budgets over the last ten years was "you should have given away more". Nobody from FG or Labour said "Hang on there, can we afford these massive increases in public sector numbers and pay" or "Can we afford these tax breaks that cause the pro-cyclical bubble that fund the massive increases in government spending that buys off all and sundry?" They may have wheezed on about fairness the odd time, particularly the self-serving double spread from Labour, but they never questioned if all that money should have been thrown around. Do you really think a government headed by a dunder-head like Enda Kenny and populated by smoked-salmon socialists, motivated by both resentment of the new rich who got their hands dirty for a living and their own upper middleclass angst and guilt, would have done anything differently? An FG with Alan Dukes and a Labour Party with Dick Spring and Ruairi Quinn (prior to the Democratic Left reverse takeover) may have been different but not that shower.
 
I'm sure the party is very proud of your ongoing attempts to deflect responsibility away from Fianna Fail, but most people will see through these feeble attempts.
Yes, it's all Fianna Fail's fault... them and the bankers and developers... God forbid any of us accept responsibility for our own actions. Get rid of them and all will be well. They are our very own wicker man.

I think I see your strategy now:
In order to fix the problem we first have to fix the blame. We then punish those that are to blame and hey presto the problem has gone away. Brilliant!

You’re not wearing a pair of ruby-red slippers by any chance?
 
The moral hazard needs to apply to politics in Ireland - you mess up, you lose power.
 
No, you just dont get it. You forget that the government is at fault for having us in this crisis to begin with. If someone else had been in power in recent years, then any comparisons with Greece would be irrelevant..


The banks in many other countries have the same trouble with banks.

Alan Greenspan was seen as vital - He made errors.

Many people in this country are little Irelanders failing to look at whats happened abroad.

The part played by many Irish in bidding up property also deserves attention.
 
No, you just dont get it. You forget that the government is at fault for having us in this crisis to begin with. If someone else had been in power in recent years, then any comparisons with Greece would be irrelevant.

I think you are displaying classic victim of bullying denial behaviour. You know you are getting a raw deal, but your confidence has been damaged so much that you think that you dont deserve any better or that you cannot survive without the bully.

Believe me, we can do a lot better.

Others have already replied to your unusual stance, I fear this is a windup (I certainly hope it is!) . .
 
Am I the only person who regards cronyism, gombeenism and corruption as being wrong?

They may have wheezed on about fairness the odd time, particularly the self-serving double spread from Labour, but they never questioned if all that money should have been thrown around. Do you really think a government headed by a dunder-head like Enda Kenny and populated by smoked-salmon socialists, motivated by both resentment of the new rich who got their hands dirty for a living and their own upper middleclass angst and guilt, would have done anything differently? An FG with Alan Dukes and a Labour Party with Dick Spring and Ruairi Quinn (prior to the Democratic Left reverse takeover) may have been different but not that shower.

I think we are approaching a watershed moment where the dymanics of Irish politics changes forever. While its a FG/Lab government is a likely outcome of the next election, I think this will only be a temporary partnership for the term of the government. The election after the next will almost certainly be FG v Labour, with FF relegated to 3rd place. Civil war politics will finally be dead and we'll mirror what happens in most western democracies i.e. centre right v centre left as being the big parties battling for power in most elections.


With regard to a FG/Labour coalition government. I'm optimistic, that true to form, the champagne socialists will be more concerned about their mercs and perks than actually implementing policies, so their impact will be minimal. I'm not a fan of Enda Kenny - but remember that we've got Jukka Brother Cowen in charge right now - would be difficult for anyone to do worse and given such a poor impression of the country to overseas investors.
 
Am I the only person who regards cronyism, gombeenism and corruption as being wrong?



I think we are approaching a watershed moment where the dymanics of Irish politics changes forever. While its a FG/Lab government is a likely outcome of the next election, I think this will only be a temporary partnership for the term of the government. The election after the next will almost certainly be FG v Labour, with FF relegated to 3rd place. Civil war politics will finally be dead and we'll mirror what happens in most western democracies i.e. centre right v centre left as being the big parties battling for power in most elections.


With regard to a FG/Labour coalition government. I'm optimistic, that true to form, the champagne socialists will be more concerned about their mercs and perks than actually implementing policies, so their impact will be minimal. I'm not a fan of Enda Kenny - but remember that we've got Jukka Brother Cowen in charge right now - would be difficult for anyone to do worse and given such a poor impression of the country to overseas investors.


No, I regard it as being wrong too. It is unfortunatly rampant and I would not presently be optimistic of seeing the end of it any time soon.
 
Back
Top