Investing in Global Commodities

S

spider7

Registered User
Messages
31
Hi, I am hoping somebody can give me some advice.
A relative of mine keeps banging on about investing in Global Commodities. Apparently Eddie Hobbs promotes theme - so they must be good!!

Basically i need to know,
what are Global Commodities?
are they a good investment?
Where can i invest in them?
(My relative says Eagle Star have a a good Global Commodities investment portfolio, any other options?)

Many Thanks in advance.
 
Two of the ways you can do this are:

1) Invest in a basket of shares that cover Energy, Base & Precious Metals & Soft Commodities (Agricultral, Coffee, Orange Juice etc)
A number of these bases would be covered on the FTSE100.

2) Invest in a Structured product that protects you initial capital & gives you direct exposure to the performance of Commodities (as above)
 
One other way that I am currently examining are Exchange Traded Commodities (ETCs) - See:

[broken link removed]

These can be traded like ETFs with any broker and the annual commission seems to be about 0.5%. Beats storing barrels of crude oil in your garage!

I am currently only reading about them and have not bought any as yet.
 
Other ways to invest in commodities include:

(1) Buy some! For example, you can buy gold directly. Search this forum for more info.

(2) Invest in a unit linked fund which specializes in commodities, e.g., this JP Morgan fund which invests in metal & energy stocks:



(While I've invested in this myself, I'm not recommending it particularly, just giving it as an example.)

(3) Use spread bets to invest in a range of commodities from gold and oil, to agricultural commodities like coffee, pork bellies or orange juice. (Be aware though that spread bets are highly-geared investments and are consequently high risk. Don't put your life savings into it!)
 
Just for clarification the JP Morgan fund is not unit linked it is a unitised fund under an Open Ended Investment Company (OEIC) based at the Luxembourg FSC and complies with UCITS transparency, auditing etc. Its an investment in the supply sidfe of the market and AA rated by S&P. Its possible to get into it at very low entry costs through its distributors.

KBC, a fund wholesaler to the retail sector is a Belgium asset manager with about 160bn under management and has been in the new cenergy and commodities sector for five years. It offers a play on Water, Eco Energy, Commodities, Emerging Markets and discretionary investment as a mixed startegy through The Innovator Fund via New Ireland a Bank of Ire subsidiary.

Both of these look like an interesting mix if put together in a portfolio. The Eagle Star fund invests in the GSCI ie Goldman Sachs Commodities Index which is based, not on mining, rigging, or technology companies in the sector but on commodity futures with a 70% emphasis on Oil Gas and metals. Nothing wrong with adding this to your basket and a mix of all three would help you diversify across this huge sector.
 
Wilkes said:
Just for clarification the JP Morgan fund is not unit linked it is a unitised fund
Click to expand...

Now I'm displaying my ignorance, which is all the more deplorable as I've already invested in the thing, but what's the difference? Is there any difference in tax treatment for example?
 
Hi Gonk, well it depends on your pov. For me guaranteed Auditing of costs of a UCITS fund is critical and while a Unit-Linked Policy issued by a Life Office may use unit accounting as a book keeping device the unit linked life fund is not subject to independent audit, just the Life Office itself.

Next comes the issue of custodianship of your money. In the UCITS JP Morgan will not hold the title documents to the fund assets ie in this case mining share certificates, hence your money does not form part of their balance sheet. This point was critical for investors through Baring Asset Managers when Barings Bank collapsed. Through a unit linked fund all monies are held on the balance sheet of the Life Office protected only by statutory compensation of €20,000 (?) or so.

Finally there is the thorny issue of costs dragging your return. In the UCITS the total expenses must be declared, simple when you've auditing. These are expressed as a % of the fund assets hence the term Total Expense Ratio, a subset of which is the AMC %. In a Unit Linked policy all you see are the front end Unit Linked Policy charges. You simply do not know what expense loading the fund is experiencing in the background for dealing costs but it would be fair to suggest that the discounts mega global groups get for everything from dealing fees to fx would be a lot more efficient than a comparatively small domestic Irish Life office.

BTW the comparison of UCITS TER vs Unit Linked fund charges is obviously invalid. The UCITS is a far better model and which also uses single unit pricing ie a price based on NAV ( net asset value). Unit Linked policies use dual pricing ie Bid / Offer spreads generally. Critics believe that this allows scope for the fund actuary to price against large movements in and out of the fund since the Bid and Offer strike prices are not independently audited but exist under the faith system ie that appointed actuaries ( paid by the Life Office) would never engage in such unfair practices.
 
Del3D said:
One other way that I am currently examining are Exchange Traded Commodities (ETCs) - See:

[broken link removed]

These can be traded like ETFs with any broker and the annual commission seems to be about 0.5%. Beats storing barrels of crude oil in your garage!

I am currently only reading about them and have not bought any as yet.
Click to expand...

the bid offer spread is high on these...not as liquid as you would like.....

http://www.askaboutmoney.com/showthread.php?t=41603&highlight=commodities
 
Has anyone invested in a specific mining INDEX?,

Currently own the MerrilL Lynch world mining fund which is doing well but would like to reduce my fee's tbh,

Basically track the underlying mining index if at all possible,

Thanks in advance
 
spider7 said:
Hi, I am hoping somebody can give me some advice.
A relative of mine keeps banging on about investing in Global Commodities. Apparently Eddie Hobbs promotes theme - so they must be good!!

Basically i need to know,
what are Global Commodities?
are they a good investment?
Where can i invest in them?
(My relative says Eagle Star have a a good Global Commodities investment portfolio, any other options?)

Spider, I am just curious as to why you think that investing in commodities must be good, just because Eddie Hobbs says so?

Have you asked Eddie about his investment experiences with commodities.

Has he done speculation trades or hedging trades?

Is he talking about the Grains, Energy, Metals, Livestock or Softs?

How long has he been at it, and has he any proof to show what he has done?

Just curious, as I tend to question everything I read, especially if someone is trying to sell something, even if it is only advice!
Click to expand...
 
no offense but when people like the above is recommended by his relative "banging on about " commodites and to invest in them , its a sure sign that the rally is nearing the end. oil is at euphoric prices at the moment,
 
mickman said:
no offense but when people like the above is recommended by his relative "banging on about " commodites and to invest in them , its a sure sign that the rally is nearing the end. oil is at euphoric prices at the moment,
Click to expand...

Well a lot of high profile analysts (Jim Rogers,George soros to name 2) reckon there's another 15 years in teh run.

Oil at euphoric prices?
The same could have been said at anytime in the last 12 months.
It has risen 85% in the last 12 months.
A lot are now talking of 150 (E.g. Boon pickens for one - a legendary energy trader).

Generally speaking it's very difficilut to pick the top in any bull run.

My advice would definitely be jump on board and get out when the trend collapses.

To the original OP - by far and away the easiest way to invest in them is through a spreadbetting company such as worldspreads or deltaindex.
 
jim rogers and george soros have been saying since the 1980's that the US economy is going to collapse and to stay away from US equities, since the 1980's we all know that US equities have risen a lot.

boon pickens said about 2months ago that he was short on oil as it was going to go to 90 dollars or below. it then went to 110 and a week ago he reversed his position and went long - why wont he be wrong again??

oil is only flying up mostly cos of the dollars decline - if the fed dont cut rates next week then watch oil come down - mark my words. gold has already topped.

commodites are too volatile for most people in invest in - my opinion for the original poster of this thread is to invest in ag companies i.e. monsanto, potash etc if he wants exposure to commodities.

the market always corrects when everyone is going around picking the next high price for a trade i.e. oil at 150 etc. thats the most dangerous time to invest, all experienced traders know this.
 
boon pickens also said that his position was a " mistake on his part" legendary trader my ass
 
mickman said:
boon pickens also said that his position was a " mistake on his part" legendary trader my ass
Click to expand...

Yes - you are right - he did reverse his position.

That said - the guy has made SERIOUS cash in investing in energies over the years.
Successful traders are nevr right all the time. It's about what they make when they are right versus what they lose when they are wrong.

WIth respect to yourself mickman - you ridiculing boon pickens for his ability to trade energy cannot be taken too seriosuly.

I'll probably give boon teh benefit of the doubt over you on this one if you don't mind.
 
mickman said:
jim rogers and george soros have been saying since the 1980's that the US economy is going to collapse and to stay away from US equities, since the 1980's we all know that US equities have risen a lot.
Click to expand...

Ok - so you're having a go at jim rogers and george soros here too i see.

Out of curiosity - is there anyone out there whose opinion is probably more informed than yourself given that you seem to have no time for jim and george either ?
 
mickman said:
no offense but when people like the above is recommended by his relative "banging on about " commodites and to invest in them , its a sure sign that the rally is nearing the end. oil is at euphoric prices at the moment,
Click to expand...

The opening post was penned in February of 2007...
 
im having a go at thes people who come on television saying this is going to happen and that is going to happen. as you say all traders are wrong some of the time, so why go on tv and give their opinions to the world when they could be wrong, lots of new people starting in the markets will be influence by them and copy their positions only to get burned.
i have learnt the hard way not to listen to cnbc interviews or bloomberg etc. sometimes i listen for a laugh . for instance there was an oil "expert" on the other day saying that he thought oil could go to 120 dollars in 3 months, what happened?? it hit 119.80 in three days. most of these guys dont have a clue.

i have great respect for these traders , but the traders you mention here i.e. pickens etc made huge sums of money in the 1970/80 commodity bull market. inflation was rampant and markets were going limit up for weeks in a row. its easy to make money in markets like that, just the same as it was easy to make money in oil over the past 5 years.
im just saying that in my opinion the dollar will not be ALLOWED to fall forever, if it goes to 1.70 then a dollar support program will be put in place and oil will fall heavily
 
mickman said:
i meant above that i have great respect for soros etc
Click to expand...

Good on you mm, you speak what is on your mind.

If one wants to play long term gambles, then that is their own decision, and they must accept what happens, good or bad.

If one has an option to play short term gambles, that are less risky, and can yield much better results, then one should consider this option seriously.

My opinion is that they are all a bunch of, oh, I better not say it, I nearly forgot myself there for a moment.

Your best advisor is straight in the mirror in front of you, but many fail to see him/her :eek:

Research, study, practice, change, study, practice, change - and eventually it will click!

Notice how the research does not repeat like the other aspects.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top