General Practice start up expenses

J

justasec

Guest
My wife is hoping to start a General Practice (she qualifies in the next 12 months). We're hoping to buy a premises so I'm trying to put together projections for it's affordability. I've asked My wife to liase with ICGP trainers/colleagues etc but she is simply too busy to obtain the financial information. Turnover is easy enough to estimate but the expenses are difficult to pin down. If someone could indicate costs associated, I'd be grateful. If you don't wish to post them on the forum, perhaps you could e-mail me. This would be a start up practice and would have one GP and no GMS list.

Thanks in advance
 
Re: General Practice expenses

Rent, receptionist(s) and her own insurance (which she has to have anyway) will be the fixed costs. Then there's phones, computers, utilities (if not covered by lease) and general medical supplies.
The rent will vary depending on where she is based and the wage bill be vary depending on the hours she works.
She should try to get work as a locum in the area she wants to be based in so that she can build up a client base that will move with her when she opens on her own.
 
Re: General Practice expenses

justasec said:
We're hoping to buy a premises.
Click to expand...

Out of interest why would you buy a premises? Im not familiar with a GP practice start up but many business start ups would initially rent so as to not to tie up large amounts of capital in a non core activity.

You should consider putting together a full business plan for the start up.
 
Re: General Practice expenses

The ICGP website, here http://[SIZE=-1]www.ic[/SIZE][SIZE=-1]gp.ie may have the information you require.

Failing that an accountant familiar with general medical practice would certainly be of considerable value to you in a start-up situation and again the ICGP may be able to help with a panel of recommendations.

I notice you make no mention of an experienced practice nurse or experienced medical receptionist, but would someone on a part-time basis or in a consultative capacity to get the business plan formulated be of use?

I'll search some more...(vanishes slowly into the ether-world).

[/SIZE]
 
Re: General Practice expenses

Thanks for your responses and advice. I've cobbled together some sensitised projections and am hoping that a bank will take us seriously. I work for one myself and so would have pretty good credit assessment skills. I have tried one bank already and was very disappointed with the approach taken. I provided all the details over the phone to a bank exec who said at the end of the conversation something akin to Computer says no. He didn't even want a formal application. Whilst I was grateful for the quick response, some proposals will never tick all the boxes and need a full assessment from a competent underwriter.

ajapale, thanks for your suggestions re renting. A few reasons why not: 1. A mortgage with moratorium period would avert the cashflow crisis and approximately equate to a rental figure anyway. 2. If we do rent initially then at some point we may look to purchase which would either mean buying the rented property or relocating to a suitable freehold property nearby which might be difficult to find. 3. The property we've found now is ideal. We hope to purchase it subject to a change of use. we will certainly put together a full business plan with cashflows for our own comfort as well as the Bank. Also, given the shortage of GP's, it would be rare for a General practice to fail once well located and providing a proper service. As such, it wouldn't be less risky than your typical start-up business.

Mathepac, a practice nurse may well be hired. Hopefully the related income should offset the expense or at least free the GP to do her job. We would of course hope to hire an experienced medical receptionist. This would be essential. Thanks for your good suggestions and if you have any more please do reply.

Justasec
 
Re: General Practice expenses

Do you really need a receptionist sitting behind the desk? Why not a virtual PA service to answer incoming calls? And a web-based booking system for appointments?
 
Re: General Practice expenses

The ICGP should be able to provide you with professional advice and indicative costs for the above which should be reasonably easy to predict. An accountant who has many GPs as clients would be able to give you ball park figures on those costs (PM me and i can recommend one such practice).
If your wife has contacts with other practices she has worked they may also be forthcoming with advice / help with figures or other peers

The most difficult yet most important figure for you is expected revenue when setting up from scratch with no client base and no GMS list.
Many recently qualified GPs who are setting up on their own actually still continue locum sessional work elsewhere to bring in regular income whilst running their own practice on other days or times.
It will be pretty difficult to predict that you will have sufficient patients who will arrive on day 1 irrespective of location as whilst important for GPs its not like opening a centra franchise. I would be prepared for it to take 3yrs very minimum to build client base and factor this in especially since you are taking on fixed costs at Day 1 such as purchasing premises.
 
Re: General Practice expenses

ajapale said:
Why not share with the board?
Click to expand...

Apologies I felt it was off-topic.
My wife owns a pharmacy + premises with additional space that might suit a GP. I was hoping the area might be suitable for justasec.
Unfortunately it wasn't.
The current tenants are leaving soon, anyone any ideas how to attract a GP?
 
Re: General Practice expenses

coppers said:
Apologies I felt it was off-topic.
My wife owns a pharmacy + premises with additional space that might suit a GP. I was hoping the area might be suitable for justasec.
Unfortunately it wasn't.
The current tenants are leaving soon, anyone any ideas how to attract a GP?
Click to expand...
Where is it?
 
Re: General Practice expenses

you are probably well upto speed on the pharmacies bill in terms of business relationships between GPs and pharmacies as it is an area which has received quite a bit of attention in recent years primarily to prevent pharmacies offering highly incentivised terms for GPs to locate in their premises and potential conflict of interests
 
Re: General Practice expenses

Jo90 said:
you are probably well upto speed on the pharmacies bill in terms of business relationships between GPs and pharmacies as it is an area which has received quite a bit of attention in recent years primarily to prevent pharmacies offering highly incentivised terms for GPs to locate in their premises and potential conflict of interests
Click to expand...

Thanks Jo, I understand there are limitations from a financial point of view.

I'm hoping the area might be the attraction and wondering how to go about making this known to a potential new GP.

Any suggestions?
 
why dont you look to advertise in the irish medical times, or ask a few GPs about possible ways to advertise. i would seek legal advice in terms of the limitations as you might be in a catch 22 - ie you want to incentivise GP to rent however legally you may be restricted. A solicitor who has dealt with such a scenario may suggest an alternative structure which might assist you in this process such as a seperate company which is not linked to the pharmacy. This may give you better lattitude in attracting such a tenant.
 
Jo90 said:
A solicitor who has dealt with such a scenario may suggest an alternative structure which might assist you in this process such as a seperate company which is not linked to the pharmacy.
Click to expand...
I'm very dubious that a legal structure could be found to breach the spirit of the relevant legislation. But, for the sake of argument, if a legal structure can be found, would you be ethically comfortable with your GP and pharmacist making such an agreement?
 
Jo
Thanks. I had a look at the IMT online and it has a small ads section which is exactly the sort of thing I’m looking for.
Will try GPs but I’m not sure they’d be quick to help me introduce competition to the area.

Complainer
The spirit of the legislation is to prevent GPs from gaining financially from prescribing. Either directly (e.g. profit share) or indirectly (e.g. reduced rent). I believe this is correct and I wouldn’t be comfortable doing something that went against this.

However, close proximity brings benefits to both businesses. I wouldn’t feel ethically compromised for gaining financially because increased footfall to a surgery brought additional pharmacy customers and vice versa. A 1-stop shop is good for customers also.

What do you both think of the following?
Absorbing initial start-up costs. E.g. making the premises wheelchair accessible or a fit out or any costs that make the premises better suited for a surgery
Do you think this is against the spirit of the legislation?

 
coppers said:

Complainer
The spirit of the legislation is to prevent GPs from gaining financially from prescribing. Either directly (e.g. profit share) or indirectly (e.g. reduced rent). I believe this is correct and I wouldn’t be comfortable doing something that went against this.

However, close proximity brings benefits to both businesses. I wouldn’t feel ethically compromised for gaining financially because increased footfall to a surgery brought additional pharmacy customers and vice versa. A 1-stop shop is good for customers also.

What do you both think of the following?
Absorbing initial start-up costs. E.g. making the premises wheelchair accessible or a fit out or any costs that make the premises better suited for a surgery
Do you think this is against the spirit of the legislation?
Click to expand...

First of all, I know absolutely nothing about this particular piece of legislation, and I wasn't aware of this restriction until it was mentioned on this thread.

In my amateur opinion, absorbing of startup costs would probably run foul of S64 (2) (b) of the Pharmacies Bill 2007, which bans any arrangement that;
(b) provides for, acknowledges or regulates a financial benefit
to any of them arising from or facilitated by the colocation
or juxtaposition described in that subsection.
Click to expand...
 
General Practice expenses

Complainer said:
Do you really need a receptionist sitting behind the desk? Why not a virtual PA service to answer incoming calls? And a web-based booking system for appointments?
Click to expand...

Do you not think a receptionist/clerk is essential to do the considerable amount of administrative work associated with a one-person business - which is what a G.P. practice is? This newly-qualified (presumably relatively-young) doctor will have her work cut out to concentrate on the treatments without also having to manage a business.

Any medical or paramedical practice takes time to establish. Its success or failure depends on the quality of the experience the first few patients through the door have. The suggestion of a previous poster that this practitioner initially continues as a part-time locum elsewhere is sensible. Given the current curb on lending banks might look more kindly on this set-up if her income is underpinning the new establishment. My instinct would be to factor in all possible services and facilities patients need and expect into the business-plan rather than a 'shoe-string budget' approach to ensure its firm establishment and success.
 
Over the last number of years I have seen a number of new GP practices set up in Dublin and surrounding counties. I have not seen one of these practices fail.

Initially there has been a quite period as the population in an area becomes aware of a new doctor, but eventually all of these practices have become busy.


There is a shortage of GPs in Dublin at the moment and as I'm sure you and your wife are aware there is a high proportion of GPs in their 50's and 60's out there who will retire in the next decade and the current shortage will become an even more acute problem.

Many of the GPs that I have seen set up in the last few years have continued to do locus. Some will do a morning session in their own practice and then do locum sessions in the afternoon. Some will do without a receptionist at the beginning, and it is possible to do without, particularly if you run your surgeries on a walk-in basis rather than by apointment.

I would suggest that a start-up surgery should have walk-in sessions anyway as it makes it easier for new patients to just walk-in off the street. You do not need a practice nurse at the beginning.

I would imagine that if you can present a good business plan to the banks you should not have too much trouble convincing one to back your wife. In the long-term if she is prepared to work as a doctor and also put the effort into running her own business then it will be very rewarding and much better than answering to someone else in the long-term.
A previous poster suggested trying to do locums in the area that she will be setting up in and that is a very good idea. Prehaps even try to find someone who wants a locum to do regular sessions. Some practices where there are male only Gps like to get a female doctor to do regular sessions on a weekly. This would be worth looking into as well.

One more thing - I think I saw D6 mentioned. This is a fairly established area and population. Sometimes it is more difficult to find new patients in an area like this as people tend to stick with the doctor that they know. There are plenty of new areas both in Dublin and on the outskirts where there is particular shortages of docs and where the established practices are not taking on new patients. This means that new-comers to these areas can find it very difficult to find a GP to take them on. This is even the case with private patients.

Make sure you do your research on location.

Best of luck.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top