TV/DVD Combis

ice

Registered User
Messages
396
Hi

I want to buy a new TV and DVD....nothing fancy, 21inch screen etc...

Have seen a few combis for arond 200 /220 or so and am wondering if these are somehow more prone to problems than a separate TV and DVD player?

thanks
 
ice said:
Hi

I want to buy a new TV and DVD....nothing fancy, 21inch screen etc...

Have seen a few combis for arond 200 /220 or so and am wondering if these are somehow more prone to problems than a separate TV and DVD player?

thanks

I would say:

PROS
  1. Probably cheaper than buying a separate TV & DVD
  2. More compact than two separate units
  3. Easier to install e.g. wall mount - one unit and less cabling.
CONS
  1. If the DVD or the TV breaks, you lose both units.
  2. The DVD can often be noisier than if you had a separate unit.
  3. You can't upgrade the DVD separately (minor point as usually a TV/DVD combo is for a bedroom or playroom and not your main TV).
  4. The tube (CRT) TV and DVD combos are not the most compact if you intend haging on the wall. There are some LCD and DVD combos (LG do one and Panasonic do one) but these are not cheap - several times your budget, in fact.
  5. I would guess that you are unlikely to find a region hack for the DVD player.
As a final thought, for the money, you will have no more worries about build quality of the DVD in the combi than a standalone DVD player at this pricepoint. Given the high cost of repair, you will probably replace the entire unit if it gets faulty in a few years time as it will not be economical to fix either component.
 
MonsieurBond said:
  1. If the DVD or the TV breaks, you lose both units.
Obviously if the TV goes you lose the DVD but how does it work the other way, surely if the DVD goes the TV could still work?
 
dam099 said:
[/list]Obviously if the TV goes you lose the DVD but how does it work the other way, surely if the DVD goes the TV could still work?

You are correct; I should say, you lose the unit that breaks.

If the DVD goes, you can of course still watch TV, or connect in an external DVD player (or wirelessly link one it via a video sender, as discussed elsewhere on AAM).

If the TV breaks, in theory you could connect the DVD via SCART to another TV but it is probably too physically awkward.