@fangs: Thanks for your input. My plan is starting to take shape now, and I've more or less decided to have two separate pension products.
I'm in the process of setting up an executive pension portfolio with Davy, which basically provides a similar platform to a normal trading account (i.e. I decide what to invest in, in terms of shares, currency etc). The other pension fund will be a managed executive plan with one of Standard Life, New Ireland, Zurich, First Active etc.
I met an independent financial advisor yesterday and asked him about what allocation rates I might achieve and he mentioned that some are as low as 95% but 97.5% would be what I should expect. So, your comment about offers of allocation rates of 103% come as a bit of a surprise. Feel free to pass on some details
Regarding the management fees, for most funds they seem to fall in the range 1 - 1.7%. It's not always the case, but it looked to me that the funds rated riskier had higher fees. To be fair, I only looked at Standard Life and New Ireland, and New Ireland's fees looked cheaper (with some falling below 1%). I'll see next week what kind offers are on the table.
As for extracting money from the company, I am totally allergic to paying myself out the cash. I just can't stomach paying 55% tax. I'll explore any other legitimate avenue and at the moment the pension is where I'm at (which is a good thing, as I don't have one). Next year I'm thinking I'll work less, i.e. earn less money, have more time off, pay less tax
@Conan: I've received feedback from both the financial advisor and another party that I can invest about 39k. In both cases, they were aware of the incorporation date of the company. That said, neither could say definitively, so you could well be correct. When I get more info, I'll post back.