I suspect you know the answer yourself.
There was a re-63 extension. You knocked it down. There is now an extension that is not pre-63. Your purchasers need to be satisfied, in relation to this development, that
a. No planning permission was needed.
b. When the works were done.
c. If the works were done in compliance with Building Regs/Building Bye Laws - much will depend on where the property is located and when the works were done.
You need a qualified architect/engineer to inspect and confirm the position in an Opinion/Certificate. And if it turns out that you needed planning permission, you are into an application for retention.
mf