Planning issues in Belfast

J

jcskinner

Guest
I have a question involving planning issues in Belfast that I'd appreciate people's advice on.
I have a large house in Belfast, which is my primary residence (the only house I own), but I spend most of the week in rented accommodation in Dublin as that's where most of my work is.
The house is way too big for me, and I engaged an architect to draw up plans to convert into three apartments, with the intention of keeping one and selling on the other two to family members.
It took the architect the guts of a year to draw up plans and send them in for planning approval, in which time the market has turned as we all know. However, I remained keen to proceed with the redevelopment.
Now, after months of silence from the planning department, we've got a fairly negative response to the plans. The architect and I went to a meeting with the planners to clarify their actual difficulties with the proposed redevelopment, and I was shocked when the meeting descended into a peeing contest between a really rude planner and my architect over who knew the regs best.
Now I'm on the verge of having the plans formally rejected. This is baffling to me because the planners have been incapable of explaining why my plans are unsuitable when literally dozens of similar redevelopments in the same area have been permitted. I'm beginning to suspect some ancient animus between my architect and the planning department.
Now my architect has suggested hiring a professional town planner for their advice on how to resubmit the plans, at a cost of a low four figure sum, which is on top of the significant five figure sum I've already paid him for plans which look like being rejected.
I want to redevelop, but don't want to throw good money after bad. What should I do?
 
Hi
I'm not a planner or a builder but have been through a few experiences in Belfast and know others who have succeeded only after 12 applications.

There are many complaints about the NI Planning service. It will be a tough call to know whether to withdraw the application BEFORE a refusal or to take it to appeal afterwards on the grounds of nearby precedants (presuming that your proposals are similar).

Worth checking whether the £10k+ you have already paid includes Planning fees, Building Control Fees and liaison with the builder during construction.

What part of Belfast?
Good luck whatever your decision.
jwf
 
Hi
I'm not a planner or a builder but have been through a few experiences in Belfast and know others who have succeeded only after 12 applications.

There are many complaints about the NI Planning service. It will be a tough call to know whether to withdraw the application BEFORE a refusal or to take it to appeal afterwards on the grounds of nearby precedants (presuming that your proposals are similar).

Worth checking whether the £10k+ you have already paid includes Planning fees, Building Control Fees and liaison with the builder during construction.

What part of Belfast?
Good luck whatever your decision.
jwf
 
The architect's fee thus far covered up to planning approval. So further tranches would be needed if we went to build phase.
The idea of a town planner has been introduced as a separate, unplanned for event with an additional charge that I'm not too happy about.
I'll PM you if you don't mind?