Ombudsman refusing to hear case where fraud is involved

Brendan Burgess

Founder
Messages
53,718
I called the financial ombudsman and they unfortunately said that because it is fraud they cannot get involved. It's a matter for the garda. .....

I moved this from this thread as it deserves a separate discussion

Bank refusing to refund fraudulent debit card transactions - thief had pin

I was not aware that the FSO was not hearing fraud cases.

From the FSO website

  1. Fraud - Section 57BZ (1)(d)
    If a complaint is considered to involve fraudulent or potentially fraudulent activity or if an allegation of fraudulent activity is made by either the Complainant or the Financial Service Provider it will not be dealt with by this office. For cases involving fraud the Complainants are advised to refer the matter to an Garda Síochána and to seek redress through a Court of Law.

I checked the legislation

57BZ.—(1) Without limiting section 57BY, the Financial Services Ombudsman can decide not to investigate a complaint, or to discontinue an investigation of a complaint, on the ground that—


(d) there is or was available to the complainant an alternative and satisfactory means of redress in relation to the conduct complained of, or



I doubt very much that the legislators had misuse of a credit card in mind when framing Section BZ(1)(d). They were probably thinking of a case where a friend of the customer defrauded him and the customer can sue the friend.

The person in this case does not have access to redress. Sure the Gardaí may catch the criminal, but what chances does she have of getting her money back?


Brendan
 
Last edited:
I don't see any difference between your case and this case from the 2008 Annual Report. [broken link removed]

It is an allegation of fraud which the bank investigated.

upload_2015-5-12_19-12-54.png

upload_2015-5-12_19-13-17.png


upload_2015-5-12_19-13-38.png
 
They won't Brendan it was referenced to a decision by Justice Peart a few years ago..its why I had to withdraw my case and go legal route proper
 
Back
Top