Key Post "My investment property is my pension."

Bronte said:
As in can I sell my investment, purchase an ARF and would I be better off?
Click to expand...

No you can't. On retirement, you can use your pension fund to buy an Approved Retirement Fund. It continues to accumulate tax-free and anything you draw down from it is taxed as income in the normal way.

Brendan
 
Bronte said:
My understanding of the pension pot is that much of it disappears when you die
Click to expand...
Not necessarily. Your point is true of DB pensions or annuities. There are many options to preserve wealth if you die.

You're a bit of an exception!
You've more than 1 property, and some free cash. So you can accept the risks.
For someone with a single property on retirement, no other assets, and no cash the risk is high. Even without a mortgage.

I'm not against property as an investment. It's something I'm exploring myself, but only because I'm already using my full tax relieved pension contributions, and I aim to have a pension pot in excess of 1m. Again, I can accept the risk of a property investment. But I'd be uncomfortable heading into retirement with a single property asset as my only retirement fund.
 
RedOnion said:
For someone with a single property on retirement, no other assets, and no cash the risk is high. Even without a mortgage.
Click to expand...

Excellent point and I have updated the initial post accordingly.

Brendan Burgess said:
Conclusion 2
It is extremely risking relying on just one property as your source of income in retirement. Even if you own it outright without a mortgage. Rents can fall. You might find it difficult to get a tenant.
Click to expand...
 
I agree
The 300k is gradually paid down by the tenants
 
I know someone in retirement with a state pension, their home and one rental and no cash. No mortgages or debt. No credit card. Is that risky. Property cost about 100 IEP I think. Rents around 300 to 350 weekly.

Edit: about rents falling. This was over about 20 years, going from about 1995. Rents fell and rose over that time period. But not by exceptional amounts in this property.
 
moneymakeover said:
I agree
The 300k is gradually paid down by the tenants
Click to expand...
Well Burgess and RedOnion don't seem to agree. I'm not sure how I'm to do the numbers that he wants though. The only person that's well able to do that is Cream Egg.

I'd also like to point out that the only people who became landlords that I saw lose out were the ones who payed crazy prices, on 100% or more borrowings, with interest only deals, where rent was never going to sort it out. Then it's risky as if you lose your job too in that scenario than you're snookered entirely. Now I think those were the Celtic Tiger Cubs, I've been around a while, and I never saw anything like that before or since. But that's a one off crazy aberration that is making everybody say property is risky. They should try buying like some of us back in the day when I was grateful to get a 9% mortgage.
 
moneymakeover said:
The 300k is gradually paid down by the tenants
Click to expand...

I am sorry, but this doesn't actually mean anything. I might as well say "my pension fund pays for my holidays"

If you want to compare investing via a pension and buying a property directly, you do an exercise like I did in the first post.

You compare the net income and capital gain of one with the other.

What you do with it is another matter.

If it makes sense to borrow to invest in a property, then it makes sense to have an interest only loan.



Brendan
 
Not only does it not "not mean anything"
It is very significant
It was mentioned independently by Bronte,

"the actual property is paid for by the rent. But a pension has to be purchase"

Investing in property is complex and to compare with buying and holding shares is difficult.

There are comparisons. One I can think of, say person borrowed money to buy shares. And used the share dividend to pay the interest and possibly capital.

Average person will never be able to buy property without borrowing.
 
The rent is effectively a dividend
Significant and usually can offset interest initially
And capital in long term
We just need to choose a dividend rate


Another factor is the tax advantage where rental income can deduct interest before calculate tax
 
Excellent thread and a well balanced opening post.

In practice most property investment is not in a pension wrapper, and most property investment uses a mortgage. Property investment without a mortgage is a very different beast.

A number of posts are conflating cash flow with profit.

Brendan Burgess said:
borrowing also magnifies the risks.
Click to expand...

Not in the simplistic straightforward manner this is usually understood. This is usually taken as invest €100 there is €100 at risk; borrow a further €100, there is €200 at risk. A mortgage contract for 25 years or whatever is an obligation to pay x euro per month. No one should take out a mortgage without a high degree of certainty that they can meet the monthly payments. If you have this high degree of certainty, then the risk is correspondingly low.

SBarrett said:
mortgage payments plus tax is usually greater than rental income, so there is a cost to the property owner while they have a mortgage.
Click to expand...

That is not a cost, its a funding requirement

Bronte said:
On the point you didn't understand. I think it should be pointed out that an investment property can be purchases out of rent, whereas pension has to come out of PAYE income.
Click to expand...
moneymakeover said:
"the actual property is paid for by the rent. But a pension has to be purchase"
Click to expand...

The funding for the monthly mortgage repayments does indeed come from the tenants whether in whole or in part.

Going back to Brendans original post, the pension investor would need to earn €166,000, and forego out €100,000 spending to fund the pension, hardly realistic for most. The property investor would need to earn €40,000 and forgo spending of €20,000 to fund the property purchase.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Menu
Log in
Register