Ministerial and TD expenses

M

Marion

Moderator
Messages
2,020
This was originally posted by allthedoyles

Such a cheeky suggestion - why not start by cutting these expense ?

From 2005 to 2008, €97,637,195.65 was paid out to TDs in salaries and expenses.
The top 30 for the period are
Rory O’Hanlon - € 789,543.77
Michael Moynihan - € 726,873.65
Bernard Allen - € 725,636.56
Noel O’Flynn - € 723,782.51
Sean Fleming - € 722,561.57
Johnny Brady - € 720,676.88
Jackie Healy-Rae - € 719,350.52
Dan Neville - € 712,660.55
Brendan Howlin - € 709,654.03
John Cregan - € 704,570.69
Padraic McCormack - € 699,120.51
Ned O’Keeffe - € 695,606.45
Dinny McGinley - € 692,391.64
Seymour Crawford - € 692,011.42
John Perry - € 691,415.49
Michael Lowry - € 690,947.20
Tom Hayes - € 690,436.23
Peter Kelly - € 684,358.22
Paul Kehoe - € 680,046.39
Michael Ring - € 679,042.87
Enda Kenny - € 676,745.95
John O’Donoghue - € 675,828.78
Phil Hogan - € 672,263.48
Niall Blaney - € 671,759.13
Pat Breen - € 669,201.01
Jim O’Keeffe - € 668,538.10
Michael Finneran - € 665,965.04
John Moloney - € 663,295.21
Beverley Flynn - € 661,031.29
John Deasy - € 659,961.01
 
These guys are not going to cut their expenses. This is only the tip of the iceberg in their earnings by the way.

But, they will continuously tell us to tighten our belts etc. Even wondered why people voted for them or why they were carried shoulder high by their hacks after being elected?
 
No. 3 Bernard Allen - € 725,636.56
Click to expand...
Is this the same fat cat TD who sits looking permanently surprised and indignant as chairman of the PAC when he hears of overspending in FAS, the HSE etc..

While wary of quoting the bible, it's hard to argue with this one
Any why seest thou the mote that is in thy brother's eye; and seest not the beam that is in thy own eye?
Click to expand...
 
Leper said:
This is only the tip of the iceberg in their earnings by the way.
Click to expand...

According to the original OP, these amounts represent salary and expenses for a four year period.

If this is the "tip of the iceberg", can you explain what other income they have?
 
Staples said:
According to the original OP, these amounts represent salary and expenses for a four year period.

If this is the "tip of the iceberg", can you explain what other income they have?
Click to expand...

TDs salary plus additional payments for serving on various oireachtas committees.
 
Marion said:
Rory O’Hanlon - € 789,543.77
Click to expand...

He was Ceann Comhairle 'til 2007, now retired. I wonder does having been CC add to his TD & Ministerial pensions ?

Marion said:
Beverley Flynn - € 661,031.29
Click to expand...

A 'class act', to quote her father

Marion said:
John O’Donoghue - € 675,828.78
John Deasy - € 659,961.01
Click to expand...

These two have been on permanent sulk in the Dail since being given the boot as CC and front-bench spokesman, respectively.
 
It would be interesting to see what their expenses are after their salaries. Without that it doesn't mean much.
It should also be noted that ministers have very low expenses (or should have) as their travel etc is covered by their department.

Why not start with a 20% pay cut for all and an end to un-vouched expenses?
 
Why not start with a 20% pay cut for all and an end to un-vouched expenses?
Click to expand...
I would go further and say average industrial wage and, of course, end to this crazy 'expenses' carry on (or 'legalised theft' as I prefer to call it)

This would ensure a higher calibre of political candidate, as being a TD should be more like a vocation, rather than a means to personal gain.
 
Being a TD is only a part time job - i.e. 3 days a week, for c.25 weeks a year, so it should be paid as such.
 
As I mentioned in another thread, Tds are probably given expenses for things other workers just have to pay for themselves.

As an example, I am guessing food. I bet they get allowances for meals. Yet I have to buy my own dinner. With their wages, could they not?
 
I don’t think cutting TD’s wages to the average industrial wage would provide a better candidate, it would just mean that politics would become the preserve of the independently wealthy (just as it was in the UK ‘till quite recently). As long as we have the electoral system we have we will get bad TD’s. As long as we have no separation between the legislative and executive we will have bad governments. The whole system needs to change.
 

I was going to make that same comment about healy-rae.

Cannot believe this money, I know that probably sounds ridiculously naive, but I really can't!
 
it would just mean that politics would become the preserve of the independently wealthy (just as it was in the UK ‘till quite recently).
Click to expand...
Do you not need bucket loads of money at the moment to run a successful election campaign?
 
TD's deserve to be well paid. What they don't deserve are the ridiculous expenses. Why should my TD's in Dublin North get paid travel expenses to go into the Dail? The State offers a very good subsidised travel plan through the tax saver scheme. Join me on the train at 6.30 in the morning. Use that or drive into work like everyone else.

That's just one example.
 
Yes, but how would cutting their pay to the average industrial wage solve that problem?
Click to expand...
There are two major problems with Irish 'democracy'. The first is that it costs bucket loads of money to run for election. This means that politics is the preserve of the independently wealthy.

The second problem is that such huge wages, pensions, perks, unvouched expenses etc, will, and does, attract the wrong calibre of candidate. Politics should be about the good of the country, not the enrichment of politicians and their cronies.

This is another policy that Sinn Fein seem to have got right.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Menu
Log in
Register