Been there a year ago for 2 weeks and while we had a great trip (we went there for a Hindu wedding so we saw the real side of Mauritius so to speak) I would have been very dissapointed if we had just went there for a regular holiday.
I think the marketing board of Mauritius have done a great job as everyone believes it to be this paradise island. However, if you are staying in hotels that cost 60-70 euro a night its not such a paradise....just a normal sun holiday and the public beaches were n't that great..crowded and small.
I would n't go back where as I would have no hesitation in going back to Thailand for example.
Did n't think the food was wonderful either....well I was expecing more. we stayed in the West side of the island in Flic en Flac and also spent some time in the north of the island.
Janeom