I can't answer the original question because I think it's a bit of the "apples and oranges" scenario.
However, I do think that percentage increases or decreases should be viewed with a lot of caution as they can be very misleading.
Example.
Profit in Year 1 €1
Profit in Year 2 €100
% increase = 10,000% !
Now, change the profit in Year 1 to €2
The % increase is now 5,000% i.e. half that of the first case.
The actual difference in the increase in profit is only €1. ( 99 as against 100)