ISI case study - Martin and his buy to let

Brendan Burgess

Founder
Messages
54,684
The final ISI case study

Net income| €1,555
Reasonable Living expenses| €737
Family home -owned with his wife

mortgage|€ 255k
value|€300k
50% of monthly payment| €821

Apartment - jointly owned with his brother

mortgage|210k
value|€130k
Rent |€900 per month
50% of monthly mortgage payment| €676

Unsecured debts: €98k

Family home

Buy to let

and

7. MARTIN’S POSITION AFTER MEETING HIS DUTIES AND OBLIGATIONS UNDER BANKRUPTCY

n) The family home is held in Monica’s sole name and Martin pays a contribution to the mortgage going forward.
 

Attachments

  • Martins buy to let bankruptcy Dec 2013.pdf
    211.4 KB · Views: 835
This seems fine, apart from the buy to let.

His brother is jointly and severally liable for the full mortgage. The Official Assignee should simply wash his hands of it. He can't tell the tenant to pay the rent to himself, no more so than any partner can tell a tenant to pay the full rent to him.

The brother is the big loser here. He ends up with the full negative equity after the bankruptcy.

I wonder how much the Official Assignee will allow Martin pay towards the mortgage in bankruptcy.

Brendan
 
In this situation, Martin would be much better off trying for some form of Debt Settlement Arrangement with his unsecured debtors.

They only get €10,000 under the bankruptcy. Maybe they would settle for €15,000 as a second mortgage on the property?

He keeps his interest in the home.

He keeps his share of the buy to let and so he doesn't sting his brother.

Brendan