Irish Life's Indexed European equity tracks the FTSQ Europe ex UK (apparently by holding stock directly that makes up the index). I believe they also make some extra money by loaning out stock. This will increase the return of the fund, and their profits, but it has a counterparty risk (which is lowered by having some collateral from the counterparty). (I think some (most?) passive ETF's also do this)
http://uk.finance.yahoo.com/q/hp?s=WIEXUKSG.L&a=03&b=19&c=2006&d=08&e=13&f=2012&g=d&z=66&y=1518
WIEXUKSG.L values were 365.08 (19-apr-2006) 337.62 (13-sep-2012)
Total fall -7.522%
Annualised fall -1.212%
So the Irish Life fund appears to have outperformed the index by .35% p.a., I assume this out-performance comes from profit from loaning out shares, which is not risk-free.
Caveats:
* maybe the irish life chart is showing the return before charges?
* I need to confirm that Index WIEXUKSG.L is the cumulative index for FTSE Europe ex UK but it looks like it is
* It appears the quoted AMC on this irish life fund is .75% (vs 1% for QL customers)
* In order to infer how "expensive" their index tracking is, we would need to know how much money they made from loaning out shares. AFAIK Quinn was not loaning out shares, so it is not an apples for apples comparison.
As an Aside - this raw index has performed considerably different to the Eurostoxx 50 one!