You should have never told the Insurance Company that the guy was renting , you should have just reported the goods stolen and said nothing about renting a room.
Besides that being an insurance scam which is why people's premiums are so high, if you want to make a claim on stolen goods, you need to report it to the Gardaí. Lying to the insurance company is one thing but lying to the Gardaí is a serious offense.
Great idea - what a genius. Insurance companies would never think anything suspicious about keeping a Playstation and games in the garden, or a garden shed, would they?