Re: Is this thread bordering on racism?
I am not sure if this response should be here or in LOS so mods please feel free to move or delete if appropriate. - I do not want to hijack this thread nor for it to descend into the farcical ranting and raving and polemics that usually accompany this subject matter in LOS.
It is my personal feeling that this thread and the comments of a number of contributors to this thread borders on racism and that the comments and posts by some people are symptomatic of a kind of "soft racism" practiced by Irish people.
Racism is defined by dictionary.com as "The belief that race accounts for differences in human character or ability ..."
I feel that by attaching ethnic descriptions to the negative behaviour of people we are (re)enforcing negative stereotypes about people and about different ethnic groups and that this is a form of racism.
If we continually use and accept such negative stereotypes they will gradually, over time, harden into much stronger feelings against certain ethnic backgrounds.
I believe that we should be actively working against this happening so that our children will grow up being tolerant of and open too people of other ethnic backgrounds.
My personal litmus test when I hear or read these kind of comments is to change the context slightly and see what impact this has - ie change African / Latvian etc., to Irish and to assume that the majority of posters are based in the UK - this, as an example only and I'm not picking on Tonka, gives us a statement along the lines of
The Welsh and Scots and French, all of whom appear on the British Roads nowadays , seem to be better drivers than the Irish .
I think the point I am trying to make in a bad and long winded way, is that whenever we differentiate based on nationality or ethnicity we are are not defeating racism but rather promoting it.
Now, before the flaming starts, I want to make clear that a. I do not think that this is deliberate on the part of the people posting ie I don't think anyone sets out to be deliberately racist and b. I myself am no angel nor paragon of virtue and have said similar and worse on many occasions.
efm