Brendan Burgess
Founder
- Messages
- 52,258
Personally I don't think people should borrow for holidays. Period.
Edit: Actually if you're saving for a house you shouldn't be going on holidays.
This amongst some other posts made by BB & ors just illustrates why this 20% requirement makes no real sense!!Now, if someone wants to go on holidays, while saving to buy a house, they should take out a loan for the holiday, so that they have the 20% deposit.
It makes perfect sense as long as the bank looks at the potential borrowers debt as well as savings.This amongst some other posts made by BB & ors just illustrates why this 20% requirement makes no real sense!!
This amongst some other posts made by BB & ors just illustrates why this 20% requirement makes no real sense!!
[FONT="]P[/FONT][FONT="]art of the over-indebtedness of households in this crisis comes from the presence of additional secured or unsecured borrowings from multiple sources. A cap on mortgage LTI does not deal with this aspect and could result in leakage through additional non-mortgage borrowing, frustrating the aims of the measure. One theoretical approach to this problem of potential leakage would be to apply a ceiling also to the household’s total debt-to-income (DTI) ratio. Such ratios take into account a borrower’s total debt and are therefore, if they can be enforced, more effective in constraining the build-up of household debt. However, this ratio requires a comprehensive view of all a borrower’s debts, which has been more difficult for the lender to obtain reliably given the absence in Ireland of a Central Credit Register. The necessary legislation to underpin such a Register is now in place and the Central Bank is creating a Register, which is expected to become operational in early 2016.[/FONT][FONT="]1[/FONT][FONT="]1 [/FONT][FONT="]T[/FONT][FONT="]h[/FONT][FONT="]e new Credit Register will be another important step in enhancing the functioning of a well-regulated and stable mortgage lending market in Ireland and will allow for further consideration of macro-prudential tools such as DTI and DSTI in future. Pending the availability of this Register, it would be premature to attempt to establish realistically enforceable regulations on total debt. Lenders must nevertheless seek to inform themselves about total borrower indebtedness and limit their lending accordingly, as per their requirements under the Consumer Protection Code 2012.[/FONT]
But I imagine that they are open to discussion on it as it's the first question they ask:DSTI ratios
DSTI limits act in a similar way to LTI limits by restricting the debt servicing cost relative to the income of the borrower. Imposing a DSTI ratio on net income is operationally difficult. In order to define the numerator of a DSTI ratio, a comprehensive view of the debt service cost, including all the borrower’s loans, and potentially under different interest rate scenarios, is needed. DSTI caps can be circumvented by increasing the term on the loan.
It is the Central Bank’s view that DSTI limits are less appropriate than LTI limits at this point in time. The Central Bank may introduce such a ratio in future.
Question 1: Which of the tools or combination of tools available to the Central Bank would, in your opinion, best meet the objective of increasing resilience of the banking and household sectors to shocks in the Irish property market and why?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?