just NEED to get this off my chest with BMW independent mechanics !
I have 1996 318i convertible. About 4 weeks ago Water temp gauge went into red - about 3 miles to home ... I put heater on full , temp came down and got home.
Looked under bonnet - saw water + steam coming from back of engine (close to bulk-head) beside a plastic pipe.
Let engine cool down , topped up with water and took it to BMW Mechanic. He opened the bonnet he said "its yer water pump mate"
...what about the steam + water... " that was just pressure getting out"
..."hope ya didnt drive it" ...as if I could carry it " might have done the headgasket" !
New waterpump and thermostat (220 euro) 2 weeks later same thing, this time no heat inside car .... I checked oil cap and dipstick no water and checked exhaust, no water . Brought it back to mechanic ." leave it with me" ..next thing the head is off, sent to be skimmed and pressure tested etc. Junior mechanic said parts were ordered and as he picked up a plastic pipe he said " its only when you strip down things you see whats wrong" ....this got me thinking my first explaination to the mechanic was right ...probably just a split hose .
(Sorry for going on) when the Main mechanic came back -I asked him why he took the head off , he said he pressure tested it and water was pouring into 4th cylinder , I asked him how come it wasnt coming out exhaust or why no water was mixed with oil ..... " thats just the way they go sometimes" ...
I have my own opinion on what it takes to damage a BMW headgasket ...
and would a pump + thermostat go together then two weeks later a headgasket ????????