Brendan Burgess
Founder
- Messages
- 53,292
Pádraig Yeates is a journalist, publicist and trade union activist.
He is a distinguished social and labour historian and the author of Lockout, the standard work on the great 1913 labour dispute.
Hi Deise
He is coming from a particular viewpoint where Jim Larkin is seen as a hero by the trade union movement.
So I would need to check him out in the same way as I wouldn't take what Kevin Myers said.
I would like to see something written by an historian.
Brendan
Perhaps for a more balanced view you should read the book or perhaps you do not care to do so based on preconceptions ?
Lockout Dublin 1913 by Padraig Yeates is pretty much the definitive account - positively reviewed by the Irish media.
Until the August 2013 book on the Lockout by John Newsinger Mr. Yeates ( a quick google suggests that it is roundly accepted that Mr. Yeates is a respected historian ) book on the lockout was the only detailed account.
I have read Mr. Yeates book & I found it extremely instructive & frank in it's descriptions of Unions & their leaders - flaws & all , but then again if people are not prepared to read the book then really it's not something that can be debated !
I have not read Mr. Newsinger's book as yet but hope to do so in the coming weeks - I should warn those of a nervous disposition that Mr. Newsinger is a Marxist !
Brendan , I'm very surprised at you !
Sure , the author is a Trade Unionist but you have simply dismissed him as being biased on that basis alone .
Perhaps for a more balanced view you should read the book or perhaps you do not care to do so based on preconceptions ?
I would prefer to read a book by someone who has not got a particular angle on the story. A historian rather than a Trade Unionist or a book written by an IBEC employee for that matter.
I think this particular topic has run it's course & as such I'm now signing off.
Well it is 4pm
Was Mother Therese solely interested in the poor, or was she booking a seat upstairs?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?