Affordable Housing ? How affodable is it ?

janedoe06

Registered User
Messages
135
Can i ask a question
Affordable housing how realistic is it

You see the income limits in some case been u p to 50,000 or 130,000 with 2 income family

How much of a hope do i have with an income of 26,500 in Cork ?

i know that rent is regarded as a form of savings by the council,
and evidence that u are able to repay

But if the mortage was pushing 800 euros it would still be very tight on my wages
what do ye think ?
 
Yeh agree there.

Even affordable's are becoming unaffordable and most, especially Affordable Initiatives are geared to those on or above average wage with sizeable deposits.
Not to worry, but 80% of the workforce earn below 34k a yr(according to budget) so there are plenty of people in the same boat who cannot afford a place to live.
If you have significant savings, it'll help alot, either that or wait and save.

Only way out is either continue renting, prices come down or save up for a huge deposit to afford that affordable!
 
I'm purchasing a property worth 250K through affordable housing with the council owning 50% through shared ownership. I earn 35K and the mortgage/rent is going to be quite tight. I think though on your salary you might qualify for a mortgage subsidy, although I don't know how much.

Best thing to do is ring the council up and ask them how much disposable income one needs to actually afford repayments.
 
I have just been offered a 2 bed affordable house after nearly 5 years on the list, I am getting mortgage from EBS over 30years at €800 approx for the first year and €900 approx after year 2. House is worth €280 buying for €190
 
Congratulations Sammieh, the wait was worth it for you. 5 years is a long time... Do you mind me asking what county/city council you are with?
 
I am on my way to purchasing a 2 bed apartment in Dublin. It cost me around €200,000 from the council. The market value (as the council estimated) was around €400,000. Therefore the clawback if I sell the place within 10 years is 50%. (see below for more details on Clawback)

The reason it was worth it for me is that if I had to buy the place with someone else I would only be getting 50% anyway if the apartment was sold. Also I can rent out the other room to go towards the mortgage, so for me it is better than buying with someone else.

The council will give you up to 5 times you salary (so around 132,500). The council buys the property for cost value and pass it onto to you for somthing similar. I would advise you to ring the sales team for you councils Affordable housing scheme. They can tell you what type of property you can expect in your area for that amount. For Fingal i was told at the time a 1 bed was around 135,000+, 2 bed 150,000+ and 3/4 bed 180,000+ depending also on the location - by the time I accepted a place that had gone up but at least you will have some idea.
You can also ask them how many people on are on the list (for me it was around 300 and I will have the keys within 10 - 12 months since applying)
[broken link removed]
Tel. Nos.: 4924015 & 4924402

I think the limit for Mortgage Subsidy is around €28,000 so you would qualify for that (not sure how much it is but I think it is decent enough). Also you would get the Mortgage Interest Relief of about €50 a month.


The rest of this is a little bit long and detailed but I found it difficult to get info about the scheme so I think a single post here might also answer some other posts on the issue that I have seen - if its in the wrong
place, my apologies, but being my first post I'm sure the modorators will forgive me.

The way it works:
(based on my experience was with Fingal Co. Co. for the Affordable Housing Scheme and not the Affordable Housing Initiave, which I think may be similar but couldn't be sure)
The infomation from the Council was not that great so it took me a while to figure some of this out.

Savings - you have to save around €700 a month from the time you apply to the time you take ownership of the house. You can include any documented rent, SSIA's as part of this. Pension AVC (Annual Voluntary Contributions) cannot be used as I tried this but they were having none of it.

Debts - I was lucky in that I had none at the time to complicate things, but I belive you can't have any. I think you can have up to €500 on a credit card.

Documentation - Fill in all the documents, the P21 from the Tax office can take a while so apply for this first.
If your lucky you might even get a few euro back from them.

Loan Approval - Presuming you have provided all the documentation correctly, you will be called for a provisional
loan interview. Here they will go throughn all the bank documentation you provided any query some of the transfers. You will then be sent a provisional loan approval letter which will be about 5 times you salary. So for you (janedoe06) they will approve a mortgage of about €130,000. Which might not seem a whole lot in the current market but the council get the house at cost price.
Also good information to have going into this interview is if you can get a GIFT (not a loan) from any other source, ie family or friends. This all goes towards the property they will ofer you. So if you could get say €20,000 (eg SSIA's) from somewhere the property offered could be for €150,000, you have to at least have a min deposit of about €10,000

You then go on a waiting list. There was 300 people on my list and I got the apartment within a year from the time I applied.

You will recieve a phone call to go for a viewing. If the council has a number of properties within an estate/apartment block all viewings will be together with other people. There will be an property for everyone.
NOTE: YOU HAVE TO MAKE A DECISION on whether to take to property on the spot that day. Alwasy say you will take a property as you can back out any time before the Final Loan Approval without penatly.
If you refuse at any stage or back out before the final loan approval you remain at the same place on the list. There is no penalty for refusing a property.

Back to the viewing - you may be shown a number of places, if there are other people there then at the end of the viewings you will be asked to choose a property based on you place on the list. So if you are at the top you get first choice. After you select a property I would advise you to have a look again at the place you selected and take photos, measurements etc as you wont have access again until the Snag.
For the viewing the council will have some information based on how much the mortgage will be depending if you go Fixed, or Variable over a certain number of years. It will also tell you the minimium deposit for the property.
For me the min deposit was €10,000. This is only for guidance as this is will be based on info at the Final Loan Approval.

You will then be called in for the Final Loan Interview, and will need uptodate copies of payslips, bank details, P21 - basically everything you provided at the start. You will decide on the mortgage and this will be based on a max of (I think it was) 35% of salary They will only use the information provided from payslips and will require a letter from the bank manager (if someone is giving you a gift) stating that they have the amount in their account or that they would be approved for a loan of that amount (again the money to you has to be a GIFT not a loan) and
they will want a letter from the person stating that they will give you this gift.

On the clawback - the clawback is applied in the following fashion 100% of the Clawback percentage for the first 10 years, if you sell, if you mortgage or if you rent the property (you can take advantage of the Rent a room scheme without penalty)
After 10 years the percentage is reduced by 10% each year for the next 10 years. So after 20 years you fully own the property.
The clawback is calculated as the
"Sale price to Applicant" / "Market Value at the time of sale to applicant" x 100
The market value from the council is not the actual market value but an estimate from a valuer as to what the market value is. I have been told this this can be more or less than what the properties are being sold for
privately. In my case the valuation was more and even though there was still a couple of unsold 2 bed apartments the councils market value was about €20,000 more than what they were being sold for.

My understanding (as I couldn't get a straight answer from the council - they insisted this was a market value and not an estimation ) is that they sell the property to the applicant for the cost price (in my case €200,000) and after that the just use the valuation as a means to calculate the clawback. Seems a bit strange that that dont just use the actual market value but there it is.

After that is the Snag - I recommend getting a professional to do it. If you do it yourself at least buy a
Snagging Checklist. I got one from Snagging.org and it was well worth the €20
 
It is shocking to hear that Fingal are overestimating the market-value of their affordable properties, and simply doubling the cost price to arrive at the valuation in order to make calculating the clawback simple. Any overvaluation will affect owners of these properties who sell their homes on. In your case, Ginty56, there is a 50% clawback on the property. You paid €200,000, but you say that Fingal agree that the property's market value is €20,000 less than that, ie, €380,000, and that similar properties in the development are still being sold for this amount. So, if you sell your home tomorrow for its market-value of €380,000, you'll receive only 50% of that back, ie, €190,000, making you about the only person in the last decade to make a loss on their home. Am I right? Bear in mind that the properties in your development selling for €380,000 possibly have kitchens etc in them, though the Affordable Homes come bare.

I am understanding from reading posts on this matter that the Affordable Housing Section of Fingal do not appear to be answerable to their clients, and do not entertain questions. I wonder is this issue of overvaluation something the Ombudsman might look into? Or indeed, is Fingal's valuation process subject to the Freedom of Information Act?
 
About the salary thing, dont take it for granted that your loan will qualify for 5x salary.
I was told at interview for Fingal that it would be 5x salary but ended up getting 4.35x instead despite steady job.
I think interest rates probably played a part in the reduced amount as they went up twice when i applied last summer!
Also i got the impression at interview stage, in order to get a 1/2/3 bed, its based on how much you can afford rather than on your needs, not sure if anyone else here has experienced this.
 
Orion's Belt - You are right in what you say and the figures you mention, if I sold at any time I would be at a loss, so my property has to increase by about €20,000 before I break even. Good point on the finish - forgot to mention it earlier - when viewing the apartment that is how you will get it without any of the "Standard Features" that all the other properties in the development are entitled to. SO I pay more for a property with a lower quality of finish - go figure.

Just to clarify
Fingal didn't just simply double the cost price to calculate the clawback - they had the cost price, got a valuation and from that calculated the calwback. However what you said may have happened as I have no idea who did the valuation, and according to what builder specifications as I have not been provided with specs even for the snag. Not sure when I will get them - or for that matter when during a normal property purchase you get them.

Fingal didn't agree that the property was overvalued they just kept repeating that their valuation was the market value, even though market value is what prople are prepared to pay for a property at a given time. So with some unsold apartments the market value should be the sale price that the other apartments are going for. I havent pushed the issue yet as am still waiting to sign the final documents but i take what you say about bringing it up with the Ombudsman and Freedom of Information.
I have found it difficult dealing with Fingal as noone seems to want to take the time explain to explain the process, so its a case of finding out as you go along.

Gurramok - Also right, the 5x salary is a maximium and its used in conjunction with 35% of your salary to calculate the actual mortgage they are willing to give you. As with any mortgage it will depend on persomal circumstances but I was just trying to give janedoe06 some idea of how it worked.

You are correct in that you are only offered properties based on what you can afford - Mortgage + Gift + Any other money you might have.
That is why it is important at the initial interview to know if you can get a gift from somewhere and for how much. If the property is not suitable to you then you can refuse without penalty and wait for another more suitable property - its a chance you take as theres no guarantee on what will come up.
 
Ginty56, maybe you should secure documentary evidence of these other fully kitted out apartments in the same development currently for sale at €380,000, and find out what they have in terms of additional fittings. Then, when you're settled in your new home, point out to Fingal that €400,000 was not actually the market value of your apartment, and seek to get the clawback adjusted to reflect the correct market value at time of purchase. The market value of your place will be lower than €380,000 as you've no fittings and fixtures. So if you sell within the next twenty years, you won't take a hit. Also remember that of the monies you put into decorating or improving the place, only 50% (the clawback) of any profits made if you sell within ten years will accrue to you. Fingal will get 50% of the money you spend on tiles, flooring, etc.

The business with the lack of specs is very high-handed and most disrespectful to you. The lack of transparency and accountability in Fingal is problematic. At €200,000 (for which you own just of half the apartment, unless you settle for two decades) this is a massive investment. It's wonderful that you got a place, however, so congratulations on it and I hope you enjoy it.
 
Ginty56, maybe you should secure documentary evidence of these other fully kitted out apartments in the same development currently for sale at €380,000, and find out what they have in terms of additional fittings. Then, when you're settled in your new home, point out to Fingal that €400,000 was not actually the market value of your apartment, and seek to get the clawback adjusted to reflect the correct market value at time of purchase. The market value of your place will be lower than €380,000 as you've no fittings and fixtures. So if you sell within the next twenty years, you won't take a hit. Also remember that of the monies you put into decorating or improving the place, only 50% (the clawback) of any profits made if you sell within ten years will accrue to you. Fingal will get 50% of the money you spend on tiles, flooring, etc.

The business with the lack of specs sounds high-handed. The lack of transparency and accountability in Fingal is problematic. At €200,000 (for which you own just of half the apartment, unless you settle for two decades) this is a massive investment. It's wonderful that you got a place, however, so congratulations on it and I hope you enjoy it
 
Thanks for the comments and advice Orion - will follow up on it and might post back in the new year if there is any devolopments
 
[quote/]You will recieve a phone call to go for a viewing. If the council has a number of properties within an estate/apartment block all viewings will be together with other people. There will be an property for everyone. [/quote]

I just wanted to advise that this isn't always the case, we viewed an apartment back in October and we were literally pipped to the post by the person before us. We viewed the property and really liked it but the person who viewed immediately before us took the last one. We were
disheartened by this as we were never advised that no of people viewing would not = the no of properties.
 
Jinxmeister I was on the kildare list, it works by a points system so depends on the circumstances!!
 
After almost three years I've just been offered a two bed apt under the affordable housing scheme with Dublin City Council.

Seem to have been offered worst apartment in complex. All other apartments benefit from either a patio, balcony or roof terrace.
My apartment has nothing. Living Room and one bedroom window open onto public covered laneway with a graffiti covered wall opposite,the development isn't gated so could be a hideout for junkies, winos, grafitti artists etc. Other bedroom window is beside entrance to apartment block. All at ground level. There is also some "green mould" around apartment.

Estate agent from Hooke and Macdonald has only given me appointments to view property at 4.30 -5 pm when there is no daylight, and some rooms in apartment had no light bulb. Estate agent assures me that I also get an underground car space although on the days I viewed she forgot to bring the keys for underground space. There is also an overground space same number as my apartment out in the outer most corner of development opposite two retail units that have public parking.
Paid my deposit and asked estate agent for a receipt she still hasn't sent it to me. Don't trust the estate agent at all. It's like she's trying to hide something.

After paying the deposit, I met two girls who said it was a nice complex, they asked what apartment I was interested in I said ground floor corner one. They said at last resident's meeting a few ground floor tenants said that they had a problem with damp in their apartments.
Getting cold feet about the apartment Maybe affordable housing isn't all it's cracked up to be. Was delighted when I got offer now I think it's just a way for developer to offload all the less desirable properties in any development.

See on internet that properties are going in the complex for €380,000 at what stage do the council let you know of their valuation. Let's say for instance that an apartment on 1st floor with balcony is going for €380,000 do I have any come back to say that I don't think my apartment is worth €380,000.

Good Luck with your apartment Ginty.
 
Can i ask a question
Affordable housing how realistic is it

You see the income limits in some case been u p to 50,000 or 130,000 with 2 income family

How much of a hope do i have with an income of 26,500 in Cork ?

i know that rent is regarded as a form of savings by the council,
and evidence that u are able to repay

But if the mortage was pushing 800 euros it would still be very tight on my wages
what do ye think ?

A friend of my partners was "offered" an "affordable" house in Cork, price was around 168k and her income is 28k a month.
They "refer" you to three institutions, none of whom will offer more than 5 times the income. So she was unable to accept the offer as she simply couldn't get the mortgage.
I told her to ask about the SOS scheme but for some absolutely ridiculous reason they will not allow people to apply for the SOS scheme or a council loan AFTER they've been offered "affordable" housing.

So increasingly these cut price homes are going to better off singles and families who are in reality priced out their preferred market (sometimes only temporarily), than out of the market per se. In other words, the people who probably would have got the houses at the original asking price in the first place, end up getting them in the end, at a discount, and nicely subsidised by taxpayers who cannot themselves afford anything.
 
Not to worry, but 80% of the workforce earn below 34k a yr(according to budget) so there are plenty of people in the same boat who cannot afford a place to live.
If you have significant savings, it'll help alot, either that or wait and save.

Only way out is either continue renting, prices come down or save up for a huge deposit to afford that affordable!

Yes, it seems it works out best for those on the higher end of the €50,000 scale alright!
Just to pick up on a point, I don't think the budget actually said 80% of people earn less than 34k, it meant that 80% of PAYE earners effectively pay no more than 20% of their gross/total income on tax. I know it's a diversion, apologies!
 
I'm on the fingal affordable housing list based on 2005 P21 salary. The limit is EUR40,000. If my current salary exceeds this will this affect my application?
 
If one is offered a house/apt under the scheme based on the previous years income but their current income exceeds the 40K limit, will they be disqualified? Or will they be in a position to receive a higher mortgage?
In my case I qualify under both 2005 and 2006 salary but my 2007 salary will exceed 40K.
 
Back
Top