@ capnhand, I concur no reason to shout this accountant down immediately.
Do some digging, ask him questions:
- ask to see his practising cert
- ask his background, where he worked? for how long? why he has gone out on his own?
- check where he is working from now?
- ask around whether anyone else you know has used him and can give a good account of dealing with him
You dont have to interview him but a good chat and you ll get a feeling for him straight away. Whether he is making it up or telling it straight.
Being qualified doesnt necessarily mean he is capable. Many accountants have been in industry for 10-15 might have lost there jobs and started into getting clients but not looked at a tax book in the interim 10-15 years. My father is a financial controller but would be very light on corporation tax knowledge for example.
Yes you might save 50% but if the guy isnt up to standard you never know what might not be claimed and what sort of mess you might end up in.