A Lesson in Irony

E

elefantfresh

Registered User
Messages
450
I thought this was rather apt....

The Food Stamp Program, administered by the U.S. Department of Agriculture, is actually proud of the fact it is distributing the greatest amount of free meals and food stamps ever.

Meanwhile, the National Park Service, administered by the U.S. Department of the Interior, asks us to "Please Do Not Feed the Animals."



Their stated reason for the policy is because the animals will grow dependent on handouts and will not learn to take care of themselves.

This concludes today's lesson.
 
I don't like this..... tongue in cheek maybe but I don't like the comparison between those requiring food parcels and animals..........the logic escapes me.

This 'lesson' is not for me! :( nuff said
 
I get it but it's a blunt oversimplification of a complex issue, to the extent that it becomes offensive.
 
Jeany - I wasn't trying to offend anyone - get a mod to take it down if we're all feeling this way.
Apologies to ye all.
 
I wouldn't worry about it, some people will read into things and always be offended.
 
Im not remotely offended - and I get it!

There was a comment passed on here before in a thread about feeding the birds about not to feed them because theyd turn into social welfare birds - and no one jumped on it - how is it different?
 
It's a stretch to compare the two.

I know it's humerous and I'm not personally offended but then again, I'm not in reciept of food parcels or St Vincent de Paul......................
 
I think it's ironic ..

.. that the OP labelled the post 'A Lesson in Irony' and offered as an example something that's not ironic :rolleyes:.

Cue Alanis Morrissette
 
I think I'm going to have to be a lot more careful when I post next time!

And please don't cue Alanis Morrissette...
 
TarfHead said:
I think it's ironic ..

.. that the OP labelled the post 'A Lesson in Irony' and offered as an example something that's not ironic :rolleyes:.

Cue Alanis Morrissette
Click to expand...

I think it is quite ironic that one department of an organisation boasts that more people than ever are dependant upon handouts whilst another discourages handouts for fear of making the recipients over-dependant.

There is sufficient incongruity present.

Thinking of Alanis Morissette, the element of Irony that was missing was the lack of incongruity. A fly in your wine might be unfortunate, but it would only be ironic if a specific reason existed why a fly in your wine might have been a particularly unexpected or notable event e.g. you had an irrational fear of flies, only ate out in winter because of it and were the one person it happened to!
 
The irony in Alanis Morrisette's song arises from the fact that none of the "examples" of irony given in the song are actually ironic!
 
DB74 said:
The irony in Alanis Morrisette's song arises from the fact that none of the "examples" of irony given in the song are actually ironic!
Click to expand...

Was is ironic that a song writer wrote a song about a word she didn't understand and yet it became a massive hit?
 
The were a scene in Reality bites where Winona (yer wan, the shoplifter) Ryder, was asked to define or explain irony. She hummed and hawed and didnt get the newspaper job. The other character explained it something like this (I'm quoting from my trusty pocket dictionary):

irony "the expression of a meaning through words whose literal sense is the opposite" - my example being "I will ya" meaning no, which is also a double positive giving a negative (as opposed to the usual double negative giving a positive)

OR

"the development of events in the opposite way to that intended or expected". This seems a bit weak - we all expect a further 'kicker' - a few of Alanis' would have passed that test. The well known sketch by, ironically (???) I cant remember his name, dissects poor Alanis on the basis that 'the kicker' is absent and all her examples are just bad luck.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top